It is probable that most of his Hymns that are
definitely controversial belong, like most of his controversial
writings, to the years of his later life, at Edessa. And as we
have seen, the earliest of them that can be confidently dated, is not
earlier than 350. But it would be hasty to conclude that he had
composed no Hymns before that date, and that in the Nisibene Hymns of the siege we have the first fruits of the vine of his vision. In 350
he must have been over forty—perhaps over fifty years of age; and
it is highly improbable that a fertility which proved to be so
abundant, did not begin to manifest itself at a much earlier age; or
that a literary offspring of such bulk and importance was all produced
in the last five and twenty years of a long life. The earlier
authorities concerning his life give no definite information on this
head; and the Syriac Life is vague in its statements and
untrustworthy in its chronology. The account given of
Barhebræus, a well-informed but very late writer (thirteenth
century), can hardly be accepted as embodying any genuine tradition,
but has probability in its favor:—“From the time of the
Nicene Council (he writes Ap. Assemani, B. O. I.
116.), Ephraim began
to write canticles and hymns against the heresies of his
time,”—for few of his hymns are without a polemic spirit,
though (as has been said) those that are purely controversial seem to
be of a later period. A much later author indeed, Georgius
“Bishop of the Arabians” (writing in 714) warns us that
there is no evidence to assign any of Ephraim’s writings to the
twenty years’ interval between the Nicene Council and the year
345—“especially (he adds) to the years before
337.” Ap.
Forget, De Vita Aphraatis, lntroductio, p. 22; see also pp.
121–126 of Forget’s Dissertation which follows; also
p. 5 of Introd. This writer,
however, is here arguing in support of the claim of Aphrahat to be an
independent author, against those who regarded him as a disciple of
Ephraim; and he rests his case on the ground that whereas the
Demonstrations of Aphrahat are (as we shall see presently) dated
from 337 to 345, no composition of Ephraim’s can be shown to have
been written so early. And it must be admitted that the earliest
date (as above noted) that can be fixed with certainty for any of
Ephraim’s innumerable productions in 350,—thirteen years
later than Aphrahat’s earlier Demonstrations.
Against this is to be set the tradition of Ephraim’s presence at
Nicæa, implying as it does that even in 325 he had made himself a
notable person,—and the probability that one who has left such
ample proof of the copiousness of his literary gift, must have begun to
exercise it before a date at which he would have passed his thirtieth
year (supposing his birth to have been in 306), or even have entered
middle life (if we place it at the beginning of the century). The
two writers were unquestionably contemporary, and as yet no sufficient
data have been discovered to determine to which of them seniority
belongs.