122 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Book rr.
same time] to kill and condemn the erring as though they
were evil?
95. But when, overcome, we agree that there are these
things,” and expressly allow that all human affairs are full of
them, they will next ask, Why, then, the Almighty God does
not take away these evils, but suffers them to exist and to
go on without ceasing through all the ages?? If we have
learned of God the Supreme Ruler, and have resolved not to
wander in a maze of impious and mad conjectures, we must
answer that we do not know these things, and have never
sought and striven to know things which could be grasped
by no powers [which we have], and that we, even thinking
it* preferable, rather remain in ignorance and want of know-
ledge than say that without God nothing is made, so that it
should be understood that by his will? he is at once both
the source of evil? and the occasion of countless miseries.
Whence then, you will say, are all these evils? From the
elements, say the wise, and from their dissimilarity ; but how
it is possible that things which have not feeling and judgment
should be held to be wicked or criminal; or that he should
1The difficulty felt by Arnobius as to the origin of evil perplexed
others also; and, as Elmenhorst has observed, some of the fathers
attempted to get rid of it by a distinction between the evil of guilt and
of punishment,—God being author of the latter, the devil of the former
(Tertullian, adv. Marcionem, ii. 14). It would have been simpler and
truer to have distinguished deeds, which can be done only if God will,
from wickedness, which is in the sinful purpose of man’s heart.
? i.e. ills.
3 Lit., ‘‘ with all the ages, in steady continuance.”
* The ms., followed by Oehler alone, reads ducetis—‘‘ and you will
think ;" while all the other edd. read, as above, ducentes.
5 Here, too, there has been much unnecessary labour. These words—
per voluntatem—as they immediately follow sine deo dicere nihil fieri—
** to say that without God nothing is made "—"were connected with the
preceding clause. To get rid of the nonsense thus created, LB. emended
dei . . . voluntate—'* without God's will;" while Heraldus regards them
as an explanation of sine deo, and therefore interprets the sentence much
as LB. Orelli gets rid of the difficulty by calling them a gloss, and
bracketing them. They are, however, perfectly in place, as will be seen
above.
nde of