Chapter XXVII.—Paul of Samosata, and the Heresy introduced by him at Antioch.
1. After Xystus had presided over the church of Rome for eleven years,2375 Dionysius,2376
namesake of him of Alexandria, succeeded him. About the same time Demetrianus2377 died
in Antioch, and Paul of Samosata2378 received that episcopate.
2375 Xystus II. was bishop only eleven months, not eleven years. See chap. 5, note 5. Eusebius’ chronology
of the Roman bishops of this time is in inextricable confusion.
2376 After the martyrdom of Xystus II. the bishopric of Rome remained vacant for nearly a year on account
of the severe persecution of Valerian. Dionysius became bishop on the 22d of July, 259, according to the
Liberian catalogue. Lipsius accepts this as the correct date. Jerome’s version of the Chron. gives the twelfth year
of “Valerian and Gallienus” (i.e. 265–266) which is wide of the mark. The Armenian Chron. gives the eighth
year of the same reign. As to the duration of his episcopate, authorities vary considerably. Eusebius (chap. 30,
§23, below) and Jerome’s version of the Chron.say nine years; the Armenian Chron.,twelve; the Liberian catalogue,
eight. Lipsius shows that nine is the correct figure, and that five months and two days are to be read instead of
the two months and four days of the Liberian catalogue. According to Lipsius, then, he was bishop until Dec.
27, 268. Dionysius of Alexandria addressed to Dionysius of Rome, while the latter was still a presbyter, one of
his epistles on baptism (see above, chap. 7, §6, where the latter is called by Eusebius a “learned and capable
man”). Another epistle of the same writer addressed to him is mentioned in chap. 9, §6. Dionysius of Alexandria’s
four books against the Sabellians were likewise addressed to him (see chap. 26, above, and Bk. VI. chap. 40, note
1). Gallienus’ edict of toleration was promulgated while Dionysius was bishop (see chap. 13, note 3).
2377 On Demetrianus, see Bk. VI. chap. 46, note 12.
2378 Paul of Samosata was one of the most famous heretics of the early Church. He was bishop of Antioch
and at the same time viceroy of Zenobia, Queen of Palmyra. Both versions of Eusebius’ Chron. put the date of
his accession to the see of Antioch in the seventh year of Valerian and Gallienus, the year of Abr. 2277 (2278),
i.e. in a.d. 259 (260); and Jerome’s version puts his deposition in the year of Abr. 2283, i.e. a.d. 265. These dates,
however, are not to be relied upon. Harnack (Zeit des Ignatius, p. 51) shows that he became bishop between 257
and 260. Our chief knowledge of his character and career is derived from the encyclical letter written by the
members of the council which condemned him, and quoted in part by Eusebius in chap. 30, below. This, as will
be seen, paints his character in very black colors. It may be somewhat overdrawn, for it was written by his enemies;
at the same time, such an official communication can hardly have falsified the facts to any great extent. We may
rely then upon its general truthfulness. Paul reproduced the heresy of Artemon (see above, Bk. V. chap. 28),
teaching that Christ was a mere man, though he was filled with divine power, and that from his birth, not merely
from his baptism, as the Ebionites had held. He admitted, too, the generation by the Holy Spirit. “He denied the
personality of the Logos and of the Holy Spirit, and considered them merely powers of God, like reason and
mind in man; but granted that the Logos dwelt in Christ in a larger measure than in any former messenger of
God, and taught, like the Socinians in later times, a gradual elevation of Christ, determined by his own moral
development, to divine dignity. He admitted that Christ remained free from sin, conquered the sin of our fore-
fathers, and then became the Saviour of the race” (Schaff). At various Antiochian synods (the exact number of
them we do not know), efforts were made to procure his condemnation, but they were not successful. Finally
Paul of Samosata, and the Heresy introduced by him at Antioch.
800
Paul of Samosata, and the Heresy introduced by him at Antioch.