Now that we have thus thoroughly
scrutinized our doctrine, it may perhaps be time to set forth and to
consider the opposing statement, examining it side by side in
comparison with our own opinion. He states it thus:—“For
while there are,” he says, “two statements which we have
made, the one, that the essence of the Only-begotten was not before its
own generation, the other that, being generated, it was before all
things, he i.e.S. Basil. does not prove either of these
statements to be untrue; for he did not venture to say that He was
before that supreme ἀνωτάτω may
be “supreme,” in the sense of “ultimate” or
“most remote,” or in the more ordinary sense of “most
exalted.” generation and
formation, seeing that he is opposed at once by the Nature of the
Father, and the judgment of sober-minded men. For what sober man could
admit the Son to be and to be begotten before that supreme generation?
and He Who is without generation needs not generation in order to His
being what He is.” Well, whether he speaks truly, when he says
that our master i.e.S. Basil. opposed his
antitheses to no purpose, all may surely be aware who have been
conversant with that writer’s works. But for my own part (for I
think that the refutation of his calumny on this matter is a small step
towards the exposure of his malice), I will leave the task of showing
that this point was not passed over by our master without discussion,
and turn my argument to the discussion, as far as in me lies, of the
points now advanced. He says that he has in his own discourse spoken of
two matters,—one, that the essence of the Only-begotten was not
before Its own generation, the other, that, being generated, It was
before all things. Now I think that by what we have already said, the
fact has been sufficiently shown that no new essence was begotten by
the Father besides that which is contemplated in the Father Himself,
and that there is no need for us to be entangled in a contest with
blasphemy of this kind, as if the argument were now propounded to us
for the first time; and further, that the real force of our argument
must be directed to one point, I mean to his horrible and blasphemous
utterance, which clearly states concerning God the Word that “He
was not.” Moreover, as our argument in the foregoing discourse
has already to some extent dealt with the question of his blasphemy, it
would perhaps be superfluous again to establish by like considerations
what we have proved already. For it was to this end that we made those
former statements, that by the earlier impression upon our hearers of
an orthodox mode of thought, the blasphemy of our adversaries, who assert
that non-existence preceded existence in the case of the Only-begotten
God, might be more manifest.