before their fall with what they became afterwards, and enlarging on the grievous injury to
the Church generally, and the distressing trial to individuals in particular, consequent upon
their defection.
But it will be asked, Is Christian doctrine to remain at a standstill? Is there to be no
progress, as in other sciences?22 Undoubtedly there is to be progress; but it must be real
progress, analogous, for instance, to the growth of the human body from infancy to child-
hood, from childhood to mature age; or to the development of a plant from the seed to the
full-grown vegetable or tree; it must be such as the elucidation of what was before obscure,
the following out into detail of what was before expressed only in general terms,23 not the
addition of new doctrine, not the rejection of old.
One difficulty which is not unlikely to perplex a simple Christian is the readiness with
which heretics appeal to Scripture, following therein the example of their arch-leader, who,
in his temptation of our Lord, dared to make use of arms drawn from that armoury.24 This
leads to the question, How are we to ascertain the true sense of Scripture? And, in the answer
to it, to a more detailed exposition of the general rule given at the outset.
Scripture, then, must be interpreted in accordance with the tradition of the Catholic
Church, our guide being antiquity, universality, consent.
With regard to antiquity, that interpretation must be held to which has been handed
down from the earliest times; with regard to universality, that which has always been held,
if not by all, at least by the most part, in preference to that which has been held only by a
few; with regard to consent, the determination of a General Council on any point will of
course be of summary authority, and will hold the first place; next to this, the interpretation
which has been held uniformly and persistently by all those Fathers, or by a majority of
them, who have lived and died in the communion of the Catholic Church. Accordingly,
whatsoever interpretation of Holy Scripture is opposed to an interpretation thus authentic-
22 § 55.
23 §§ 55–60. For instances in point, he might have referred to the enlargement and expansion of the earlier
Creed, first in the Nicene, afterward in the Constantinopolitan Formulary. Thus, in the Definition of the Faith
of the Council of Chalcedon, the Fathers are careful to explain that they are making no addition to the original
deposit, but amply unfolding and rendering more intelligible what before had been less distinctly set forth:
“Teaching in its fulness the doctrine which from the beginning hath remained unshaken, it decrees, in the first
place that the Creed of the 318 (the original Nicene Creed) remain untouched; and on account of those who
impugn the Holy Spirit, it ratifies and confirms the doctrine subsequently delivered, concerning the essence of
the Holy Spirit, by the hundred and fifty holy Fathers, (the Constantinopolitan Creed), which they promulgated
for universal acceptance, not as though they were supplying some omission of their predecessors, but testifying
in express words in writing their own minds concerning the Holy Spirit.”
24 §§ 65 sqq.
301
Introduction.