Chapter 42.—51. For what I just now said is put with the greatest clearness in that very
epistle of mine, in answering which he has said nothing; and I would beg of you to listen
for a few moments to what he there has done. And although you are partisans of his, and
hate us, yet, if you can, bear it with equanimity. For in his former epistle, to the first portion
of which—the only portion which had then come into our hands—I had in the first instance
made my reply, he had so rested the hope that is found in baptism in the baptizer, as to say,
"For everything consists of an origin and root; and if anything has not a head, it is nothing."
Since then Petilianus had said this, not wishing anything to be understood by the origin and
root and head of baptizing a man, except the man by whom he might be baptized, I made
a comment, and said "We ask, therefore, in a case where the faithlessness of the baptizer is
undetected, if then the man whom he baptizes receives faith and not guilt? if then the baptizer
is not his origin and root and head, who is it from whom he receives faith? where is the
origin from which he springs? where is the root of which he is a shoot? where the head which
is his starting-point? Can it be that, when he who is baptized is unaware of the faithlessness
of his baptizer, it is then Christ who is the origin and root and head?" This therefore I say
and exclaim now also, as I did there as well: "Alas for human rashness and conceit! Why
do you not allow that it is always Christ who gives faith, for the purpose of making a man
a Christian by giving it? Why do you not allow that Christ is always the origin of the
Christian, that the Christian always plants his root in Christ, that Christ is the Head of the
Christian? Will it then be urged that, even where spiritual grace is dispensed to those that
believe by the hands of a holy and faithful minister, it is still not the minister himself who
justifies, but that One of whom it is said, ‘He justifieth the ungodly’?2408 But unless we admit
this, either the Apostle Paul was the head and origin of those whom he had planted, or
Apollos the root of those whom he had watered, rather than He who had given them faith
in briefing; whereas the same Paul says, ‘I have planted, Apollos watered; but God gave the
increase. So that neither is he that planteth anything, neither he that watereth; but God that
giveth the increase.’2409 Nor was the apostle himself their root, but rather He who says, ‘I
am the vine, ye are the branches.’2410 How, too, could he be their head, when he says that
‘we, being many, are one body in Christ,’2411 and expressly declares in many passages that
Christ Himself is the Head of the whole body? Wherefore, whether a man receives the sac-
rament of baptism from a faithful or a faithless minister his whole hope is in Christ, that he
fall not under the condemnation, that ‘Cursed is he that placeth his hope in man!’"2412
2408 Rom. iv. 5.
2409 1 Cor. iii. 6, 7.
2410 John xv. 5.
2411 Rom. xii. 5.
2412 Book I. c. 5, 6.
Chapter 42
1230
Chapter 42