Jerome’s
Apology for Himself Against the Books of Rufinus.
Addressed to Pammachius and
Marcella from Bethlehem,
a.d.
402.
————————————
Book I.
The documents which Jerome had
before him when he wrote his Apology were (1) Rufinus’
Translation of Pamphilus’ Apology with the Preface prefixed to it
and the book on the Falsification of the Books of Origen, (2) the
Translation of the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
and
Rufinus’ Preface, (3) The Apology of Rufinus addressed to
Anastasius (see p. 430), and (4) Anastasius’ letter to John of
Jerusalem (p. 432 Apol. ii, 14, iii, 20). He had also other letters of
Anastasius like that addressed to the Bishop of Milan (Jerome Letter
95. See also Apol. iii, 21). But he had not the full text of
Rufinus’ Apology (c. 4, 15). He received letters from Pammachius
and Marcella, at the beginning of the Spring of 402, when the Apology
written at Aquileia at the end of 400 had become known to
Rufinus’ friends for some time. They had been unable to obtain a
full copy, but had sent the chief heads of it, and had strongly urged
Jerome to reply. At the same time his brother Paulinianus who had been
some three years in the West, returned to Palestine by way of Rome, and
there heard and saw portions of Rufinus’ Apology, which he
committed to memory (Apol. i, 21, 28) and repeated at Bethlehem. To
these documents Jerome replies.
The heads of the First Book are
as follows.
1. It is hard that an old friend
with whom I had been reconciled should attack me in a book secretly
circulated among his disciples.
2. Others have translated
Origen. Why does he single me out?
3. He gave me fictitious praise
in his Preface to the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
. Now,
since I defend myself, he writes 3 books against me as an
enemy.
4, 5. He spoke of me as united
in faith with him; but what is his faith? Why are his books kept
secret? I can meet any attack.
6. I translated the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
because
you demanded it, and because his translation slurred over
Origen’s heresies.
7. My translation put away
ambiguities, and showed the real character of the book, and of the
previous translation.
8. My translation of
Origen’s Commentaries created no excitement; his first
translation, of Pamphilus’ Apology, roused all Rome to
indignation.
9. But the work was really
Eusebius’s, who tells us that Pamphilus wrote nothing.
10. After the condemnation of
Origen by Theophilus and Anastasius, it would be wise in Rufinus to
give up this pretended defence.
11. I had praised Eusebius as
well as Origen only as writers; and was forced to condemn them as
heretics. Why should this be taken amiss?
12. I wrote a friendly letter to
Rufinus, which my friends kept back.
13. There is nothing to blame in
my getting the help of a Jew in translating from the Hebrew.
14. There is nothing strange in
my praising Origen before I knew the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
15. The accusations seem inconsistent, but I knew them only by
report.
16. The office of a
commentator.
17. We must distinguish methods
of writing, and not expect a vulgar simplicity in the various
compositions of cultured men.
18. My assertion was true, that
Origen permitted the use of falsehood.
19. The accusation about a
mistranslation of Ps. ii is easily explained.
20. In the difficulties of the
translator and the commentator we must get help where we
can.
21. In the Commentary on
Ephesians I acted straightforwardly in giving the views of Origen and
others.
22. As to the passage “He
hath chosen us before the foundation of the world.”
23. As to the passage “Far
above all rule and authority &c.”
24. As to the passage
“That in the ages to come &c.”
25. As to “Paul the
prisoner of Jesus Christ.”
26. As to “The body fitly
framed &c.”
27. I quoted Origen’s
views as, “According to another heresy.”
28, 29. As to “Men loving
their wives as their own bodies.”
30. To the charge of reading
secular books I reply that I remember what I learned in
youth.
31. Also, a promise given in a
dream must not be pressed. Why should such things be raked up by old
friends against one another?
32. I am right in my contention
that all sins are remitted in baptism.