But the Bishop endeavoured to convince him,
reasoning with him thus: ‘How is it possible for me to do this
against Athanasius? how can we condemn a man, whom not one At
Alexandria. Council only, but a second At
Sardica. assembled from all parts of the world, has
fairly acquitted, and whom the Church of the Romans dismissed in peace?
who will approve of our conduct, if we reject in his absence one, whose
presence Vid.
Apol. Ar. 29. amongst us we gladly welcomed, and
admitted him to our communion? This is no Ecclesiastical Canon; nor
have we had transmitted to us any such tradition παράδοσις, vid. §14. from the Fathers, who in their turn received
from the great and blessed Apostle Peter Apol. Ar. §35..
But if the Emperor is really concerned for the peace of the Church, if
he requires our letters respecting Athanasius to be reversed, let their
proceedings both against him and against all the others be reversed
also; and then let an Ecclesiastical Council be called at a distance
from the Court, at which the Emperor shall not be present, nor any
Count be admitted, nor magistrate to threaten us, but where only the
fear of God and the Apostolical rule τῶν
ἀποστόλων
διάταξις, cf. §34. shall prevail;
that so in the first place, the faith of the Church may be secure, as
the Fathers defined it in the Council of Nicæa, and the supporters
of the Arian doctrines may be cast out, and their heresy anathematized.
And then after that, an enquiry being made into the charges brought
against Athanasius, and any other besides, as well as into those things
of which the other party is accused, let the culprits be cast out, and
the innocent receive encouragement and support. For it is impossible
that they who maintain an impious creed can be admitted as members of a
Council: nor is it fit that an enquiry into matters of conduct should
precede the enquiry concerning the faith Vid.
Pallavicin. Conc. Trid. vi. 7. Sarpi. Hist. ii.
37.;
but all diversity of opinions on points of faith ought first to be
eradicated, and then the enquiry made into matters of conduct. Our Lord
Jesus Christ did not heal them that were afflicted, until they shewed
and declared what faith they had in Him. These things we have received
from the Fathers; these report to the Emperor; for they are both
profitable for him and edifying to the Church. But let not Ursacius and
Valens be listened to, for they have retracted their former assertions,
and in what they now say they are not to be trusted.’