Turning to the contents, we find enough to convert
suspicion into a practical certainty that the documents are
forgeries. This is the opinion of M. l’abbé Duchesne
(the editor of the Liber Pontificalis), M. L. Guérard
(Mélanges d’Archéologie et d’Histoire, p.
44 sqq., 1890); Mr. Hodgkin (Italy and her Invaders, Vol.
vi., p. 501 sqq.). A false date (the beginning of
Leo’s reign is placed in the XIVth. instead of the XVth. indiction), and the false implication that
the Imperial territory of the “Ducatus Romæ”
terminated at twenty-four stadia, or three miles, from Rome, point to
an author who was neither a contemporary of Leo nor a resident in
Rome. But the insolent tone of the letters is enough to condemn
them. Gregory II. would never have addressed to his sovereign the
crude abuse with which these documents teem. Another objection
(which I have never seen noticed) is that in the First Letter the
famous image of Christ which was pulled down by Leo, is stated to have
been in the “Chalkoprateia” (bronzesmith’s quarter),
whereas, according to the trustworthy sources, it was above the
Chalkâ gate of the Palace.