SCIENCE
had been even more unfortunate than the Chair of Medicine.
History in those days was apparently little in favour with
Scottish students, probably because they could ill afford to pay
fees for extra classes. However that may be, attempts to form
a History Class had been uniformly abortive at St. Andrews, as
at the other Scottish Universities. One of the unfortunate
occupants of the St. Andrews Chair said he had fought away
with a family almost starving, and he had never made as much
from fees as paid the paper, pens, and ink that wrote his lectures.
His successor, in order to draw the attention of students to
historical studies, proposed to limit his lectures to one per
month, a novel plan which a Dublin colleague was said to
have adopted with great success, but the proposal did not find
favour with the Commissioners. On the Chair of History
becoming vacant in 1850, Dr. William Macdonald was
accordingly appointed Professor, with the duty of lecturing on
both Civil and Natural History. This unnatural alliance was
ratified by ordinance in 1862; but practical divorce ensued, as
Dr. Macdonald in his twenty-five years' occupancy of the chair
is understood to have held but one class in Civil History. His
courses in Natural History, described as " a kind of cosmogony,"
were also, it must be said, scanty and irregular.
A very different regime began when, in 1875, a distinguished
naturalist, Dr. Henry Alleyne Nicholson, succeeded to the chair.
Civil History—for which special provision has since been made—
was, of course, discarded, and regular courses of lectures in
Zoology and Geology were given in alternate years. Dr. Nicholson
was a lucid lecturer, an excellent teacher, and an attractive per-
sonality. Before coming to St. Andrews he had been Professor
of Natural History and Botany at Toronto, and of Biology in the
University ofDurham (College of Physical Science, Newcastle) ;
he was transferred from St. Andrews to Aberdeen in 1882 as
Regius Professor of Natural History. His numerous memoirs
177