all, Nature. Aristotle varies, but nevertheless assigns a unity of power: for at one time he
says that Mind, at another the World, is God; at another time he sets God above the world.
1776 Heraclides of Pontus also ascribes, although in various ways, a divine mind to God.
Theophrastus, and Zeno, and Chrysippus, and Cleanthes are indeed themselves of many
forms of opinion but they are all brought back to the one fact of the unity of providence.
For Cleanthes discoursed of God as of a mind, now of a soul, now of air, but for the most
part of reason. Zeno, his master, will have the law of nature and of God, and sometimes the
air, and sometimes reason, to be the beginning of all things. Moreover, by interpreting Juno
to be the air, Jupiter the heaven, Neptune the sea, Vulcan to be fire, and in like manner by
showing the other gods of the common people to be elements, he forcibly denounces and
overcomes the public error. Chrysippus says almost the same. He believes that a divine
force, a rational nature, and sometimes the world, and a fatal necessity, is God; and he follows
the example of Zeno in his physiological interpretation of the poems of Hesiod, of Homer,
and of Orpheus. Moreover, the teaching of Diogenes of Babylon is that of expounding and
arguing that the birth of Jupiter, and the origin of Minerva, and this kind, are names for
other things, not for gods. For Xenophon the Socratic says that the form of the true God
cannot be seen, and therefore ought not to be inquired after. Aristo the Stoic 1777 says that
He cannot at all be comprehended. And both of them were sensible of the majesty of God,
while they despaired of understanding Him. Plato has a clearer discourse about God, both
in the matters themselves and in the names by which he expresses them; and his discourse
would be altogether heavenly, if it were not occasionally fouled by a mixture of merely civil
belief. Therefore in his Timæus Plato’s God is by His very name the parent of the world,
the artificer of the soul, the fabricator of heavenly and earthly things, whom both to discover
he declares is difficult, on account of His excessive and incredible power; and when you
have discovered Him, impossible to speak of in public. The same almost are the opinions
also which are ours. For we both know and speak of a God who is parent of all, and never
speak of Him in public unless we are interrogated. 1778
1776 The ms. here inserts, “Aristoteles of Pontus varies, at one time attributing the supremacy to the world,
at another to the divine mind.” Some think that this is an interpolation, others transfer the words to Theophrastus
below.
1777 Otherwise, “Aristo the Chian.”
1778 [See note on Plato, chap. xxvi.]
417
Argument: Moreover, the Poets Have Called Him the Parent of Gods and Men,…