mained a silent hearer. The account of the above meeting is given in the treatise: De Gestis
cum Emerito, Cæsariensi Donatistarum Episcopo liber unus. [Cp. Retractt. II. li.]
The book de Patientia is assigned to 418 A.D. In Chapter xiii. he contrasts genuine and
false martyrdom.
Dulcitius had been appointed Tribune-notary. The effect of his carrying out of the re-
newed edicts against the Donatists was signalized by many conversions, but also by many
suicides. He had written to Augustin requesting directions about how he ought to proceed
against the heretics. Augustin replies [Ep. cciv.], c. 420 A.D., that his work had indeed per-
suaded many to return to their salvation, but others were stirred either to kill the Catholics
or themselves. We indeed do desire the return of all to unity, yet some are doubtless predes-
tinated to perish by an occult yet just decree of God. They perish not only in their own fires
but in that of Gehenna. The Church grieves over them as David over his son, although they
have met the deserved punishment of rebels. Augustin does not find fault with the notary’s
edict at Thamugada, only with the phrase: You may know that you are to be given over to
401
the death which you deserve; for that is not contained in the rescripts. In the second edict
there is a clearer statement of the notary’s aim. Augustin also criticizes his courtesy toward
Gaudentius, the Donatist bishop of Thamugada. As to a special reply to that bishop Augustin
urges a more diligent refutation of the fallacious doctrines by which the Donatists are accus-
tomed to be seduced. He had already done this in very many works, but adds some points
by way of suggestion. He alone is a martyr who dies for a true cause. Man’s will is free, but
nevertheless amenable to divine and human laws. The State can punish not only adulteries
and homicides, but also sacrileges. Many think it strange that we do not rebaptize, but the
sacrament once given ought not to be repeated. Suicides are utterly prohibited by the
Scriptures. The case of Razius gives the Donatist no pretext, for the deed is simply mentioned
but not commended. (II. Mac. xiv. 37–46). In conclusion he intimates that in answer to
the united wish of the people of Thamugada, of himself and of Eleusinus, the tribune of that
place, that Augustin should answer both epistles of Gaudentius, the Donatist bishop, and
especially the latter of the two, which contained Scriptural proofs, he will write such a criti-
cism.
Dulcitius had written a pacific letter to Gaudentius, the Donatist bishop of Thamugada,
one of the quieter members of the seven Donatist disputants, concerning the enforcement
of the imperial edicts. Gaudentius replied in two epistles, one short, the other longer and
fortified by Scripture proofs. Augustin was requested to answer these, which he does (c.
420) in the work Contra Gaudentium Donatistarum Episcopum, Libra duo. In Book I. he
makes a change of form from the Petilian cast of personal dialogue, because of the captious
fault found with that way as savoring of untruth, and takes a duller formula, "Verba Epistolæ"
and "ad hæc responsio," whose dryness and literality the most sensitive Donatist could take
no exception to. In the first epistle of Gaudentius, the fairly courteous strain in which he
684
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.