413
Introduction on the Date of the Council.
(Hefele, Hist. Councils, Vol. II., pp. 86 et seqq.)
Our inquiries concerning the Synod of Sardica must begin with a chronological exam-
ination of the date of this assembly. Socrates and Sozomen place it expressly in the year 347
a.d., with the more precise statement that it was held under the Consuls Rufinus and Euse-
bius in the eleventh year after the death of Constantine the Great, therefore after the 22d of
May, 347, according to our way of reckoning.
This was the most general view until, rather more than a hundred years ago, the learned
Scipio Maffei discovered at Verona, the fragment of a Latin translation of an old Alexandrian
chronicle (the Historia Acephala), and edited it in the third volume of the Osservazioni Lit-
terarii in 1738. This fragment contains the information that on the 24th Phaophi (October
21), under the Consuls Constantius IV. and Constans II., in the year 346, Athanasius had
returned to Alexandria from his second exile. As it is universally allowed, however, as we
shall presently show more clearly, that this return certainly only took place about two years
after the Synod of Sardica, Mansi hence saw the necessity of dating this synod as early as
the year 344. In this he is confirmed by St. Jerome, in the continuation of the Eusebian
chronicle, who, in accordance with the Historia Acephala, has assigned the return of St.
Athanasius to the tenth year of the reign of the Emperor Constantius, in 346.
Many learned men now followed Mansi, the greater number blindly; others, again,
sought to contradict him, at first the learned Dominican, Mamachi; then Dr. Wetzer (Pro-
fessor at Freiburg); and latterly, we ourselves in a treatise, “Controversen über die Synode
von Sardika,” in the Tübinger Theol. Quartalschrift, 1852. Soon after there was a fresh dis-
covery. Some of the Paschal Letters of St. Athanasius, which until then were supposed to
be lost, were discovered in an Egyptian monastery, with a very ancient preface translated
into Syriac, and were published in that language by Cureton in London, and in the year
1852 in German by Professor Larsow, at the Grey Friars Convent, in Berlin.
Among these Festal Letters, the nineteenth, intended for Easter 347, and therefore
composed in the beginning of that year, had been rewritten in Alexandria, as the introduction
expressly states. This confirms the statement of the Historia Acephala, that Athanasius was
already returned to Alexandria in October, 346, and confirms the chief points of Mansi’s
hypothesis; while, on the other hand, it unanswerably refutes, by Athanasius’ own testimony,
the statements of Socrates and Sozomen (which, from their dependence on each other, only
count as one), with reference to the date 347.
As we said, Mansi placed this Synod in the year 344; but the old preface to the Festal
Letters of St. Athanasius dates it in the year 343, and in fact we can now only hesitate between
the dates 343 and 344. If the preface were as ancient and as powerfully convincing as the
Festal Letters themselves, then the question concerning the date of the Council of Sardica
would be most accurately decided. As, however, this preface contains mistakes in several
Introduction on the Date of the Council.
756
Introduction on the Date of the Council.