That Justin died a martyr’s death is the universal tradition
of antiquity, which is crystallized in his name. Irenæus (Adv.
Hær. I. 28. 1) is the first to mention it, but does so
casually, as a fact well known. The only account of his martyrdom which
we have is contained in the Acta Martyrii Justini Philosophi
(Galland. I. 707 sq.), which, although belonging to a later age
(probably the third century), yet bear every evidence of containing a
comparatively truthful account of Justin’s death. According to
these Acts, Justin, with six companions, was brought before Rusticus,
prefect of Rome, and by him condemned to death, upon his refusal to
sacrifice to the gods. The date of his martyrdom is very difficult to
determine. There are two lines of tradition, one of which puts his
death under Antoninus Pius, the other under Marcus Aurelius. The latter
has the most in its favor; and if we are to accept the report of the
Acta Justini (which can be doubted least of all at this point),
his death took place under Rusticus, who, as we know, became prefect of
Rome in 163. Upon the date of Justin’s death, see especially
Holland, in Smith and Wace, III. p. 562 sq.