it could fashion a large variety of other tools. Thus the limit of the energy is to be found in
the work which it produces. But the question now is not about the amount of the energy,
but about the being of that which has put forth the energy. In the same way, if he asserts
that he can perceive the nature of the Only-begotten in the Spirit (Whom he styles the work
of an energy which ‘follows’ the Son), his assertion has no foundation; for here again the
energy, while it extends itself into its work, does not reveal therein the nature either of itself
or of the agent who exerts it.
But let us yield in this; grant him that beings are known in their energies. The First being
is known through His work; and this Second being is revealed in the work proceeding from
Him. But what, my learned friend, is to show this Third being? No such work of this Third
is to be found. If you insist that these beings are perceived by their energies, you must confess
that the Spirit’s nature is imperceptible; you cannot infer His nature from any energy put
forth by Him to carry on the continuity. Show some substantiated work of the Spirit, through
which you think you have detected the being of the Spirit, or all your cobweb will collapse
at the touch of Reason. If the being is known by the subsequent energy, and substantiated
energy of the Spirit there is none, such as ye say the Father shows in the Son, and the Son
in the Spirit, then the nature of the Spirit must be confessed unknowable and not be appre-
hended through these; there is no energy conceived of in connexion with a substance to
75
show even a side glimpse of it. But if the Spirit eludes apprehension, how by means of that
which is itself imperceptible can the more exalted being be perceived? If the Son’s work,
that is, the Spirit according to them, is unknowable, the Son Himself can never be known;
He will be involved in the obscurity of that which gives evidence of Him: and if the being
of the Son in this way is hidden, how can the being who is most properly such and most
supreme be brought to light by means of the being which is itself hidden; this obscurity of
the Spirit is transmitted by retrogression164 through the Son to the Father; so that in this
view, even by our adversaries’ confession, the unknowableness of the Fathers being is clearly
demonstrated. How, then, can this man, be his eye ever so ‘keen to see unsubstantial entities,’
discern the nature of the unseen and incomprehensible by means of itself; and how can he
command us to grasp the beings by means of their works, and their works again from them?
164 κατὰ ἀνάλυοιν. So Plutarch, ii. 76 E. and see above (cap. 25, note 6.).
141
He falsely imagines that we can have an unalterable series of harmonious…