10. Finally, do not even the leaders and founders of the schools3461 already mentioned,
say those very things3462 which they do say through belief in their own ideas? For, did
Heraclitus see things produced by the changes of fires? Thales, by the condensing of wa-
ter?3463 Did Pythagoras see them spring from number?3464 Did Plato see the bodiless forms?
Democritus, the meeting together of the atoms? Or do those who assert that nothing at all
can be comprehended by man, know whether what they say is true, so as to3465 understand
that the very proposition which they lay down is a declaration of truth?3466 Since, then, you
have discovered and learned nothing, and are led by credulity to assert all those things which
you write, and comprise in thousands of books; what kind of judgment, pray, is this, so
unjust that you mock at faith in us, while you see that you have it in common with our
readiness of belief?3467 But you say you believe wise men, well versed in all kinds of learn-
ing!—those, forsooth, who know nothing, and agree in nothing which they say; who join
battle with their opponents on behalf of their own opinions, and are always contending
fiercely with obstinate hostility; who, overthrowing, refuting, and bringing to nought the
one the other’s doctrines, have made all things doubtful, and have shown from their very
want of agreement that nothing can he known.
3461 Sententiarum is read in the first ed. by Gelenius, Canterus, and Ursinus, and seems from Crusius to be
the ms. reading. The other edd., however, have received from the margin of Ursinus the reading of the text,
sectarum.
3462 In the first ed., and that of Ursinus, the reading is, nonne apud ea, “in those things which they say, do
they not say,” etc., which Gelenius emended as in the text, nonne ipsa ea.
3463 Cf. Diog. Lært. ix. 9, where Heraclitus is said to have taught that fire—the first principle—condensing
becomes water, water earth, and conversely; and on Thales, Arist., Met., A, 3, where, however, as in other places,
Thales is merely said to have referred the generation and maintenance of all things to moisture, although by
others he is represented as teaching the doctrine ascribed to him above. Cf. Cic., de Nat. Deor., i. 10, and Herac-
lides, Alleg. Hom., c. 22, where water evaporating is said to become air, and settling, to become mud.
3464 There is some difficulty as to the reading: the ms., first ed., and Ursinus give numero s-c-ire, explained
by Canterus as meaning “that numbers have understanding,” i.e., so as to be the cause of all. Gelenius, followed
by Canterus, reads -os scit—“does Pyth. know numbers,” which is absurdly out of place. Heraldus approved of
a reading in the margin of Ursinus (merely inserting o after c), “that numbers unite,” which seems very plausible.
The text follows an emendation of Gronovius adopted by Orelli, -o ex-ire.
3465 So the ms., reading ut; but Orelli, and all edd. before him, aut—“or do they.”
3466 i.e., that truth knowable by man exists.
3467 So the ms. reading nostra in-credulitate, for which Ursinus, followed by Stewechius, reads nostra cum.
Heraldus conjectured vestra, i.e., “in your readiness of belief,” you are just as much exposed to such ridicule.
Chapter X.
1003
Chapter X.