The
chief accusations urged against the early Christians by their
antagonists were atheism, cannibalism, and incest. These charges were
made very early. Justin Martyr (Apol. I. 26) mentions them, and
Pliny in his epistle to Trajan speaks of the innocent meals of the
Christians, implying that they had been accused of immorality in
connection with them. (Compare, also, Tertullian’s Apol.
7, 8, and Ad Nationes, 7.) In fact, suspicions arose among the
heathen as soon as their love feasts became secret. The persecution in
Lyons is to be explained only by the belief of the officers that these
and similar accusations were true. The Christians commonly denied all
such charges in toto, and supported their denial by urging the
absurdity of such conduct; but sometimes, as in the present case, they
endeavored to exonerate themselves by attributing the crimes with which
they were charged to heretics. This course, however, helped them little
with the heathen, as the latter did not distinguish between the various
parties of Christians, but treated them all as one class. The statement
of Eusebius in the present case is noteworthy. He thinks that the
crimes were really committed by heretics, and occasioned the
accusations of the heathen, and he thus admits that the charges were
founded upon fact. In this case he acts toward the heretics in the same
way that the heathen acted toward the Christians as a whole. This
method of exonerating themselves appears as early as Justin Martyr
(compare his Apol. I. 26). Irenæus also (I. 25, 3), whom
Eusebius substantially follows in this passage, and Philaster (c. 57),
pursue the same course.