13. Therefore let them tell us, from what teacher
or by what tradition they derived these notions concerning the Saviour?
“We have read,” they will say, “in the Proverbs,
‘The Lord created me a beginning of His ways unto His works Prov. viii.
22,
and cf. Orat. ii. throughout.;’” this Eusebius and his fellows
used to insist on Eusebius of Nicomedia quotes it in his Letter to Paulinus, ap.
Theodor. Hist. i. 5. And Eusebius of Cæsarea, Demonstr.
Evang. v. 1., and you write me
word, that the present men also, though overthrown and confuted by an
abundance of arguments, still were putting about in every quarter this
passage, and saying that the Son was one of the creatures, and
reckoning Him with things originated. But they seem to me to have a
wrong understanding of this passage also; for it has a religious and
very orthodox sense, which had they understood, they would not have
blasphemed the Lord of glory. For on comparing what has been above
stated with this passage, they will find a great difference between
them i.e.
‘Granting that the primâ facie impression of this
text is in favour of our Lord’s being a creature, yet so many
arguments have been already brought, and may be added, against His
creation, that we must interpret this text by them. It cannot mean that
our Lord was simply created, because we have already shewn that
He is not external to His Father.’. For what man of right understanding does not
perceive, that what are created and made are external to the maker; but
the Son, as the foregoing argument has shewn, exists not externally,
but from the Father who begat Him? for man too both builds a house and
begets a son, and no one would reverse things, and say that the house
or the ship were begotten by the builder Serap. 2, 6. Sent. Dion. §4., but
the son was created and made by him; nor again that the house was an
image of the maker, but the son unlike him who begat him; but rather he
will confess that the son is an image of the father, but the house a
work of art, unless his mind be disordered, and he beside himself.
Plainly, divine Scripture, which knows better than any the nature of
everything, says through Moses, of the creatures, ‘In the
beginning God created the heaven and the earth Gen. i. 1.;’ but of the Son it introduces not
another, but the Father Himself saying, ‘I have begotten Thee
from the womb before the morning star Ps. cx. 3.;’ and
again, ‘Thou art My Son, this day have I begotten Thee Ps. ii. 7..’ And the Lord says of Himself in the
Proverbs, ‘Before all the hills He begets me Prov. viii.
25.;’ and concerning things originated and
created John speaks, ‘All things were made by Him John i. 3.;’ but preaching of the Lord, he says,
‘The Only-begotten Son, who is in the bosom of the Father, He
declared Him Ib. 18.’ If then son, therefore not
creature; if creature, not son; for great is the difference between
them, and son and creature cannot be the same, unless His essence be
considered to be at once from God, and external to God.