26. Coming to the Gospel he sets before us Zacharias and
Elizabeth, Peter and his mother-in-law, and, with a shamelessness to
which we have now grown accustomed, fails to understand that they, too,
ought to have been reckoned among those who served the Law. For the
Gospel had no being before the crucifixion of Christ—it was
consecrated by His passion and by His blood. In accordance with this
rule Peter and the other Apostles (I must give Jovinianus something now
and then out of my abundance) had indeed wives, but those which they
had taken before they knew the Gospel. But once they were received into
the Apostolate, they forsook the offices of marriage. For when Peter,
representing the Apostles, says to the Lord: Matt. xix. 27. “Lo we have left all and followed
thee,” the Lord answered him, Luke xviii. 29, 30.
“Verily I say unto you, there is no man that hath left house or
wife, or brethren, or parents, or children for the kingdom of
God’s sake, who shall not receive manifold more in this time, and
in the world to come eternal life.” But if, in order to show that
all the Apostles had wives, he meets us with the words 1 Cor. ix. 5. The text has been much tampered with by
the advocates or opponents of celibacy. The reading first quoted by
Jerome is that of F, a manuscript of the eighth or ninth century, and
is found in Tertullian; the other chief readings introduce the Greek
equivalent for sister, either in the sing. or plural. The Rev.
Version renders, “have we no right to lead about a wife
that is a believer” (or sister). Augustine, Tertullian,
Theodoret, &c., together with Cornelius-a-Lapide and Estius among
the moderns, agree with Jerome in referring the passage to holy women
who ministered to the Apostles as they did to the Lord Himself. The
third canon of Nicæa is supposed to be directed against the
practice encouraged by this interpretation of the Apostle’s
words. “Have we no right to lead about
women or wives” (for γυνή in Greek has both meanings)
“even as the rest of the apostles, and Cephas, and the brethren
of the Lord?” let him add what is found in the Greek copies,
“Have we no right to lead about women that are sisters, or
wives?” This makes it clear that the writer referred to other
holy women, who, in accordance with Jewish custom, ministered to their
teachers of their substance, as we read was the practice with even our
Lord himself. Where there is a previous reference to eating and
drinking, and the outlay of money, and mention is afterwards made of
women that are sisters, it is quite clear, as we have said, that we
must understand, not wives, but those women who ministered of their
substance. And we read the same account in the Old Testament of the
Shunammite who was wont to welcome Elisha, and to put for him a table,
and bread, and a candlestick, and the rest. At all events if we take
γυναίκας to mean
wives, not women, the addition of the word sisters
destroys the effect of the word wives, and shews that they were
related in spirit, not by wedlock. Nevertheless, with the exception of
the Apostle Peter, it is not openly stated that the Apostles had wives;
and since the statement is made of one while nothing is said about the
rest, we must understand that those of whom Scripture gives no such
description had no wives. Yet Jovinianus, who has arrayed against us
Zacharias and Elizabeth, Peter and his wife’s mother, should
know, that John was the son of Zacharias and Elizabeth, that is, a
virgin was the offspring of marriage, the Gospel of the law, chastity
of matrimony; so that by a virgin prophet the virgin Lord might be both
announced and baptized. But we might say concerning Peter, that he had
a mother-in-law when he believed, and no longer had a wife, although in
the Attributed to
Clement by Jerome. “Sentences” we read of
both his wife and daughter. But for the present our argument must be
based wholly on Scripture. He has made his appeal to the Apostles,
because he thinks that they, who hold the chief authority in our moral
system and are the typical Christian teachers, were not virgins. If,
then, we allow that they were not virgins (and, with the exception of
Peter, the point cannot be proved), yet I must tell him that it is to
the Apostles that the words of Isaiah relate: Isa. i. 9. “Except the Lord of hosts had
left unto us a small remnant, we should have been as Sodom, we should
have been like unto Gomorrah.” So, then, they who were by birth
Jews could not under the Gospel recover the virginity which they had
lost in Judaism. And yet John, one of the disciples, who is related to
have been the youngest of the Apostles, and who was a virgin when he
embraced Christianity, remained a virgin, and on that account was more
beloved by our Lord, and lay upon the breast of Jesus. And what Peter,
who had had a wife, did not dare ask, S. John xiii. 25. he requested John to ask. And after the
resurrection, when Mary Magdalene told them that the Lord had risen, S. John xx. 4. they both ran to the sepulchre, but
John outran Peter. And when they were fishing in the ship on the lake
of Gennesaret, Jesus stood upon the shore, and the Apostles knew not
who it was they saw; S. John xxi. 7 sq. the virgin
alone recognized a virgin, and said to Peter, “It is the
Lord.” Again, after hearing the prediction that he must be bound
by another, and led whither he would not, and must suffer on the cross,
Peter said, “Lord what shall this man do?” being unwilling
to desert John, with whom he had always been united. Our Lord said to him, “What is
that to thee if I wish him so to be?” Whence the saying went
abroad among the brethren that that disciple should not die. Here we
have a proof that virginity does not die, and that the defilement of
marriage is not washed away by the blood of martyrdom, but virginity
abides with Christ, and its sleep is not death but a passing to another
state. If, however, Jovinianus should obstinately contend that John was
not a virgin, (whereas we have maintained that his virginity was the
cause of the special love our Lord bore to him), let him explain, if he
was not a virgin, why it was that he was loved more than the other
Apostles. But you say, S. Matt. xvi. 18.the Church
was founded upon Peter: although S. Matt. xviii. 18: S. John xx. 22, 23.elsewhere
the same is attributed to all the Apostles, and they all receive the
keys of the kingdom of heaven, and the strength of the Church depends
upon them all alike, yet one among the twelve is chosen so that when a
head has been appointed, there may be no occasion for schism. But why
was not John chosen, who was a virgin? Deference was paid to age,
because Peter was the elder: one who was a youth, I may say almost a
boy, could not be set over men of advanced age; and a good master who
was bound to remove every occasion of strife among his disciples, and
who had said to them, S. John xiv. 27. “Peace I
leave with you, my peace I give unto you,” and, S. Matt. xx. 27: S. Luke xxii. 26.“He that is the greater among
you, let him be the least of all,” would not be thought to afford
cause of envy against the youth whom he had loved. We maybe sure that
John was then a boy because ecclesiastical history most clearly proves
that he lived to the reign of Trajan, that is, he fell asleep in the
sixty-eighth year after our Lord’s passion, as I have briefly
noted in my treatise on Illustrious Men. See this book
in Vol. III. of this series. Peter is an Apostle, and John is an
Apostle—the one a married man, the other a virgin; but Peter is
an Apostle only, John is both an Apostle and an Evangelist, and a
prophet. An Apostle, because he wrote to the Churches as a master; an
Evangelist, because he composed a Gospel, a thing which no other of the
Apostles, excepting Matthew, did; a prophet, for he saw in the island
of Patmos, to which he had been banished by the Emperor Domitian as a
martyr for the Lord, an Apocalypse containing the boundless mysteries
of the future. Tertullian, more over, relates that he was sent to Rome,
and that having been plunged into a jar of boiling oil he came out
fresher and more active than when he went in. But his very Gospel is
widely different from the rest. Matthew as though he were writing of a
man begins thus: “The book of the Generation of Jesus Christ, the
son of David, the son of Abraham;” Luke begins with the
priesthood of Zacharias; Mark with a prophecy of the prophets Malachi
and Isaiah. The first has the face of a man, on account of the
genealogical table; the second, the face of a calf, on account of the
priesthood; the third, the face of a lion, on account of the voice of
one crying in the desert, Is. xl. 3.“Prepare ye the way of the
Lord, make His paths straight.” But John like an eagle soars
aloft, and reaches the Father Himself, and says, S. John i. 1. “In the beginning was the Word,
and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. The same was in the
beginning with God,” and so on. The virgin writer expounded
mysteries which the married could not, and to briefly sum up all and
show how great was the privilege of John, or rather of virginity in
John, the Virgin Mother S. John xix. 26, 27. was entrusted
by the Virgin Lord to the Virgin disciple.