Chapter XV
.—
Council of Ariminum
545
.
When
all who defended the faith had been removed, those who moulded
the
mind of
the emperor according to their own will, flattering themselves that the
faith which they opposed might be easily subverted, and Arianism
established in its stead, persuaded Constantius to convene the Bishops
of both East and West at Ariminum
546
, in order to
remove from the Creed the terms which had been devised by the Fathers
to counteract the corrupt craft of Arius,—“substance
547
,” and “of one substance
548
.” For they would have it that these
terms had caused dissension between church and church. On their
assembling in synod the partizans of the Arian faction strove to trick
the majority of the bishops, especially those of cities of the Western
Empire, who were men of simple and unsophisticated ways. The body of
the Church, they argued again and again, must not be torn asunder for
the sake of two terms which are not to be found in the Bible; and,
while they confessed the propriety of describing the Son as in all
things “
like
” the Father, pressed the omission of
the word “
substance
” as unscriptural. The motives,
however, of the propounders of these views were seen through by the
Council, and they were consequently repudiated. The orthodox bishops
declared their mind to the emperor in a letter; for, said they, we are
sons and heirs of the Fathers of the Council of Nicæa, and if we
were to have the hardihood to take away anything from what was by them
subscribed, or to add anything to what they so excellently settled, we
should declare ourselves no true sons, but accusers of them that begat
us. But the exact terms of their confession of faith will be more
accurately given in the words of their letter to
Constantius.
Letter
549
written to the Emperor
Constantius by the Synod assembled at Ariminum.
“Summoned, we believe, at
the bidding of God, and in obedience to your piety, we bishops of the
Western Church assembled in synod at Ariminum in order that the faith
of the Church Catholic might be set forth, and its opponents exposed.
After long consideration we have found it to be plainly best for us to
hold fast and guard, and by guarding keep safe unto the end, the faith
established from the first, preached by Prophets, and Evangelists, and
Apostles, through our Lord Jesus Christ, warden of thy empire, and
champion of thy salvation. For it is plainly absurd and unlawful to
make any change in the doctrines rightly and justly defined, and in
matters examined at Nicæa with the cognisance of the right
glorious Constantine, thy Father and Emperor, whereof the teaching and
spirit was published and preached that mankind might hear and
understand. This faith was destined to be the one rival and destroyer
of the Arian heresy, and by it not only the Arian itself, but likewise
all other heresies were undone. To this faith to add aught is verily
perilous; from it to subtract aught is to run great risk. If it have
either addition or loss, our foes will feel free to act as they please.
Accordingly Ursacius and Valens, declared adherents and friends of the
Arian dogma, were pronounced separate from our communion. To keep their
place in it, they asked to be granted a
locus penitentiæ
and pardon for all the points wherein they had owned themselves in
error; as is testified by the documents written by themselves, by means
of which they obtained favour and forgiveness. These events were going
on at the very time when the synod was meeting at Milan, the presbyters
of the church of Rome being also present. It was known that
Constantine, who, though dead, is worthy of remembrance, had, with all
exactitude and care, set forth the creed drawn up: and now that, after
receiving Baptism, he was dead, and had passed away to the peace which
he deserved. We judged it absurd for us after him to indulge in any
innovation, and throw a slur on all the holy confessors and martyrs who
had devised and formulated this doctrine, in that their minds have ever
remained bound by the old bond of the Church. Their faith God has
handed down even to the times of thy own reign, through our Lord Jesus
Christ, by Whose grace such empire is thine that thou rulest over all
the world. Yet again those pitiable and wretched men, with lawless
daring, have proclaimed themselves preachers of their unholy opinion,
and are taking in hand the overthrow of all the force of the truth. For
when at thy command the synod assembled, then they laid bare their own
disingenuous desires. For they set about trying through villany and
confusion to make innovation. They got hold of certain of their own
follow
ing—one Germanius
550
, and Auxentius
551
, and Caius
552
, promoters of
heresy and discord, whose doctrine, though but one, transcends a very
host of blasphemies. When, however, they became aware that we were not
of their way of thinking, nor in sympathy with their vicious projects,
they made their way into our meeting as though to make some other
proposal, but a very short time was enough to convict them of their
real intentions. Therefore in order to save the management of the
Church from falling from time to time into the same difficulties, and
to prevent them from being confounded in whirlpools of disturbance and
disorder, it has seemed the safe course to keep what has been defined
aforetime fixed and unchanged, and to separate the above-named from our
communion. Wherefore we have sent envoys to your clemency to signify
and explain the mind of the synod as expressed in this letter. These
envoys before all things we have charged to guard the truth in
accordance with the old and right definitions. They are to inform your
holiness, not as did Ursacius and Valens, that there will be peace if
the truth be upset; for how can the destroyers of peace be agents of
peace? but rather that these changes will bring strife and disturbance,
as well on the rest of the cities, as on the Roman church. Wherefore we
beseech your clemency to receive our envoys with kindly ears and gentle
mien, and not to suffer any new thing to flout the dead. Suffer us to
abide in the definition and settlement of our Fathers, whom we would
unhesitatingly declare to have done all they did with intelligence and
wisdom, and with the Holy Ghost. The innovation now sought to be
introduced is filling the faithful with unbelief, and unbelievers with
credulity
553
.
“We beg you to order
bishops in distant parts, who are afflicted alike by advanced age and
poverty, to be provided with facilities for travelling home, that the
churches be not left long deprived of their bishops.
“And yet again this one
thing we supplicate, that nothing be taken from or added to the
established doctrines, but that all remain unbroken, as they have been
preserved by your father’s piety, and to our own day. Let us toil
no longer nor be kept away from our own dioceses, but let the bishops
with their own people spend their days in peace, in prayer, and in
worship, offering supplication for thy empire, and health, and peace,
which God shall grant thee for ever and ever. Our envoys, who will also
instruct your holiness out of the sacred Scriptures, convey the
signatures and salutations of the bishops.”
The letter was written, and the
envoys sent, but the high officers of the Imperial Court, though they
took the despatch and delivered it to their master, refused to
introduce the envoys, on the ground that the sovereign was occupied
with state affairs. They took this course in the hope that the bishops,
annoyed at delay, and eager to return to the cities entrusted to their
care, would at length be compelled themselves to break up and disperse
the bulwark erected against heresy. But their ingenuity was frustrated,
for the noble champions of the Faith despatched a second letter to the
emperor, exhorting him to admit the envoys to audience and dissolve the
synod. This letter I subjoin.
The Second Letter of the Synod
to Constantius.
“To Constantius the
Victorious, the pious emperor, the bishops assembled at Ariminum send
greeting.
“Most illustrious lord and
autocrat, we have received the letter of your clemency, informing us
that, in consequence of occupations of state, you have hitherto been
unable to see our envoys. You bid us await their return, that your
piety may come to a decision on the object we have in view, and on the
decrees of our predecessors. But we venture in this letter to repeat to
your clemency the point which we urged before, for we have in no way
withdrawn from our position. We entreat you to receive with benign
countenance the letter of our humility, wherein now we make answer to
your piety, and the points which we have ordered to be submitted to
your benignity by our envoys. Your clemency is no less aware than we
are ourselves how serious and unfitting a state of things it is, that
in the time of your most happy reign so many churches should seem to be
without bishops. Wherefore once again, most glorious autocrat, we
beseech you that, if it be pleasing to your humanity, you will command
us to return to our churches before the rigour of winter, that we may
be able, with our people, as we have done and ever do, to offer most
earnest prayers for the health and wealth of
your empire to Almighty God,
and to Christ His Son, our Lord and Saviour.”
545
a.d.
359.
546
The
eastern bishops were summoned to Seleucia, in Cilicia; the western to
Ariminum, (Rimini). “A previous Conference was held at Sirmium,
in order to determine on the creed to be presented to the bipartite
Council.…The Eusebians struggled for the adoption of the
Acacian Homœon
, which the Emperor had already both received
and abandoned, and they actually effected the adoption of the
‘like in all things according to the Scriptures,’
a
phrase in which the semi-Arians, indeed, included their
‘like
in substance’
or
Homϟsion,
but which did
not necessarily refer to substance or nature at all. Under these
circumstances the two Councils met in the autumn of
a.d.
359, under the nominal superintendence of the
semi-Arians; but, on the Eusebian side, the sharp-witted Acacius
undertaking to deal with the disputatious Greeks, the overbearing and
cruel Valens with the plainer Latins.” (Newman,
Arians,
iv. §4.) At Seleucia there were 150 bishops; at Ariminum
400.
547
οὐσία
548
ὁμοούσιον
549
This
letter exists in Ath.
de Syn. Arim. et Seleu
., Soc. ii. 39, Soz.
iv. 10, and the Latin of Hilarius (Fr. viii.), which frequently differs
considerably from the Greek.
550
Germanus
(Ath. and Soz.), Germinius (according to Hilarius), bishop of Cyzicus,
was translated to Sirmium,
a.d.
356. The creed
composed by Marcus of Arethusa with the aid of Germinius, Valens and
others, is known as “the dated creed,” from the minuteness,
satirized by Athanasius, with which it specifies the day (May 22,
a.d.
XI. Kal. Jun.), in the consulate of Eusebius
and Hypatius (Ath. de Syn. §8).
551
Auxentius, the elder, bishop of Milan, succeeded Dionysius in 355,
and occupied the see till his death in 374, when Ambrose was chosen to
fill his place. Auxentius, the younger, known also as Mercurinus, was
afterwards set up by the Arian Court party as a rival bishop to
Ambrose. A third Auxentius, a supporter of the heretic Jovinianus, is
mentioned in the Epistle of Siricius. Vide reff. in Baronius and
Tillemont. An Auxentius, Arian bishop of Mopsuestia, is mentioned by
Philostorgius, v. 1. 2.
552
A
Pannonian bishop. Ath. ad Epict.
553
The
word in the text is
ὠμότητα
,
which is supposed to have stood for
crudelitatem,
a clerical
error for
credulitatem
in the Latin original.