The date of the martyrdom of Symeon is quite uncertain. It has
been commonly ascribed (together with the martyrdom of Ignatius) to the
year 106 or 107, upon the authority of Eusebius’ Chron.,
which is supposed to connect these events with the ninth or tenth year
of Trajan’s reign. But an examination of the passage in the
Chron., where Eusebius groups together these two events and the
persecutions in Bithynia, shows that he did not pretend to know the
exact date of any of them, and simply put them together as three
similar events known to have occurred during the reign of Trajan (cf.
Lightfoot’s Ignatius, II. p. 447 sqq.). The year of
Atticus’ proconsulship we unfortunately do not know, although
Wieseler, in his Christen-Verfolgungen der Cæsaren, p. 126,
cites Waddington as his authority for the statement that Herodes
Atticus was proconsul of Palestine from 105 to 107; but all that
Waddington says (Fastes des prov. Asiat., p. 720) is, that since
the proconsul for the years 105 to 107 is not known, and Eusebius puts
the death of Symeon in the ninth or tenth year of Trajan, we may assume
that this was the date of Atticus’ proconsulship. This, of
course, furnishes no support for the common opinion. Lightfoot, on
account of the fact that Symeon was the son of Clopas, wishes to put
the martyrdom earlier in Trajan’s reign, and it is probable that
it occurred earlier rather than later; more cannot be said. The great
age of Symeon and his martyrdom under Trajan are too well authenticated
to admit of doubt; at the same time, the figure 120 may well be an
exaggeration, as Lightfoot thinks. Renan (Les Evangiles, p. 466)
considers it very improbable that Symeon could have had so long a life
and episcopate, and therefore invents a second Symeon, a great-grandson
of Clopas, as fourth bishop of Jerusalem, and makes him the martyr
mentioned here. But there is nothing improbable in the survival of a
contemporary of Jesus to the time of Trajan, and there is no warrant
for rejecting the tradition, which is unanimous in calling Symeon the
son of Clopas, and also in emphasizing his great age.