Those who deny that
the XV. Anathemas were adopted by the Fifth Synod agree in assigning
them to the “Home Synod,” that is a Synod at Constantinople
of the bishops subject to it, in a.d.
543. Hefele takes this view and advocates it with much cogency,
but confesses frankly, “We certainly possess no strong and
decisive proof that the fifteen anathematisms belong to the
Constantinopolitan synod of the year 543; but some probable grounds for
the opinion may be adduced.” Hefele.
Hist. Councils, Vol. IV., p. 223. This
appears to be a somewhat weak statement with which to overthrow so much
evidence as there can be produced for the opposite view. For the
traditional view the English reader will find a complete defence in E.
B. Pusey, What is of Faith with regard to Eternal
Punishment?