TRUE FAITH
James 2:21-26
(a) In The Case of Abraham
21 Was not Abraham our father justified by works,---To establish his thesis that faith, apart from works, is useless and vain, James turns to the father of the Hebrew rare (Abraham), and offers him as an example of the fact that works are vital in God's plan. These to whom James wrote included many Jewish people : and those who were not would, as Christians. be interested in. and would soon acquire a knowledge of, one who occupied such a prominent place in the history of the Lord's people in earlier dispensations; and his example would, therefore, be most impressive. Further !\braham is the spiritual ancestor of all '"who walk in the steps of" his faith today (Romans 4:1-25) ; and all who are Christ's. are "Abraham's seed, and heirs according to the promise" (Galatians 3:29). The principle involved in Abraham's justification is, therefore, illustrative of the manner in which all men are justified today. The case of the illustrious father of the ] ewish people is frequently rited. for this purpose, in the Scriptures both Old and New. (Genesis 12:1-3; Genesis 15:1-20; Genesis 17:1-8; Hebrews 11:8-18; Galatians 3:15-29) ; and ] ames' reference thereto was neither novel nor unusual. It was just the instance which would be the most impressive to the people to whom he wrote.
(1) Abraham was "justified," (edikaiothe, first aorist passive indicative of dikaio, to pronounce or declare one to be just): i.e .. he was counted, reckoned, pronounced, declared to he in a right rrlationship with God. The basic significanre of the word translated ''justified," is that of acquittal ; one justified is not regarded as an enemy of God; thence forth no state oi alienation between such a man and God exists. Thus, to be justified is to be acquitted -thereafter to be in a relationship with God which he approves. "For by thy words thou shalt be justified, and by thy words thou shalt be condemned." (Matthew 12:37.) "And by him every one that believeth is justified from all things. from which ye could not be justified by the law of Moses." (Acts 13:39.) It follows. therefore, that one who is justified is by the Lord regarded (counted, reckoned, declared to be) innocent of any charges formerly made. The verdict has been rendered; one justified is declared not guilty.
(2) Abraham was justified "by works." The words, "Was not Abraham our father justified by works . ... " Translate the Greek phrase, Abraam ho pater hemon ouk ex ergon edikaiothe, the negative ouk indicating that an affirmative answer is expected. Thus, even the objector who alleges that faith, without works, produces a blessing, must concede that, in Abraham's case, justification was by works. The preposition "by" (Greek, ex, out of), points to the source of Abraham's justification; it was out of works that he was justified, not by means of works. Works, as such, are not efficacious; God, it is, who declares one just; but God does it out of works-that is, he issues the verdict when the works appear. Only God can justify; but God justifies only when the works, which he prescribes, appear. The verdict of justification results from the works.
Hence, no works, no justification! There was a definite time and place when Abraham was justified. When was it?
in that he offered up Isaac his son upon the altar?----It will be noted that the phrase "in that," with which this portion of the verse begins is, in the King James Translation, "When . .. " The meaning is the same. Inasmuch as the verb is aorist (which indicates an action contemporary with, or prior to the action of the main verb), the meaning here is that the declaration of Abraham'~ justification, and his offering of Isaac were simultaneous; i.e., out of (ek) the one-the offering-the other-justification occurred. For the story of Abraham and his offering of his son Isaac, see Genesis 22:1-19, and compare Hebrews 11:17-19.
22 Thou seest that faith wrought with his works,---James points his objector to the obvious truth of that he had just penned. It was easy to see, in this historic incident, that Abraham's faith wrought (exercised itself) with his works in offering up his son Isaac. "Wrought with," is from sunergei, imperfect active of stmergeo, to cooperate with; hence, faith and works kept on cooperating with each other to produce the result-Abraham's justtification.
and by works was faith made perfect;---It was "by" (Greek, ek out of) works that faith, in Abraham's case, was "made perfect." The phrase, "made perfect," is from eteleiothe, aorist passive inwcative of teleio, to consummate, to complete, to finish. The tenses in this verse are highly significant. Faith was continually exercising itself (imperfect tense) with works (the command to offer up Isaac on the altar), and out of these works iaith was perfected at once (aorist tense). Neither works, nor faith operating alone can justify; each in cooperation with the other produces that status wherein God justifies.
23 and the scripture was fulfilled which saith, And Abraham believed God, and it was reckoned unto him for righteousness;---Scripture alluded to here is that found in Genesis 15:6 : "And he believed in Jehovah; and he reckoned it to him for righteousness." This was affirmed of Abraham after the illustrious patriarch had accepted, without question, and despite his childlessness, and the advanced ages of himself and his wife Sarah, God's promise of vast posterity. Not knowing at the time how such could be, he nevertheless believed that it would be and stumbled not at the promise of God in unbelief. This scripture (Genesis 15:6), is declared to have been fulfilled when Abraham's faith was made perfect. It is vitally important lo observe when the scripture referred to was fulfilfod. Though Abraham was earlier (Genesis 15:6), acknowledged as a believer, and his faith "reckoned" for righteousness, it was not until later (Genesis 22:1-19), that his faith was consummated (made perfect) in the act of obedience involving Isaac. Abraham believed God, prior to this act of obedience; i.e., he fully accepted God's word, and relied implicitly on the promises which it contained; and, as a result, his faith "was reckoned unto him for righteousness ... . " "To reckon," (elogisthe) is to regard, deem, consider, account; hence, God deemed, considered, regarded Abraham's faith as righteousness (right-doing).
Faith itself, thus became an act of obedience which, in its exercise, and when, at the moment, there were no additional duties devolving rtpon Abraham, God accepted as proof of Abraham's devotion. One must not irom this assume that the exercise of belief bestowed upon Abraham blessings apart from and independent of any obedience; though this conclusion is often drawn, it is an erroneous and hurtful one. In the nature oi the case, the promise of great posterity involved matters which would require considerable time for their development; hence, there was nothing more, at the moment, ior Abraham to do but to accept, without hesitation, the assurances oi such from God. This, he did; and his acceptance thereof, became an act of righteousness which God, in his tum, accepted, and put to Abraham's account for righteousness (right-doing). It is a violent perversion of this passage and historic incident from it to assume that because Abraham's faith was accepted as an act of righteousness when there was nothing else required of him at tire time that in our case faith will suffice without the performance of those conditions which are required of us now. Even in Abraham's case, as James so clearly shows, the patriarch's faith did not reach its consummation, its fulfillment, until it had translated itself into action in the offering of Isaac.
and he was called the friend of God.---That is, Abraham was, and was called "the friend of God"; i.e., God's friend. The phrase, "of God," is not an objective genitive, "friend of God," meaning that Abraham regarded God as his friend (though doubtless he did), but a subjective genitive, he was one whom God considered as his friend! "Didst not thou, o· our God, drive out the inhabitants of this land before thy people Israel, and give it to the seed of Abraham, thy friend for ever ?" (2 Chronicles 20:7.) God regarded Abraham as his friend because he was ever faithful to God, and always submitted his will to God's. Jesus said, "Ye are my friends if ye do the things which 1 command you." (John 15:14.)
24 Ye see that by works a man is justified, and not only by faitb.--- This is the irresistible conclusion to be drawn from the preceding premises. Any reasonable person must, on careful and prayerful consideration of the foregoing affirmations of the sacred writer, readily see that faith blesses only when it leads the one exercising it to faithful compliance with the commands of God. James' conclusion is established (1) by analogy (verses 14, 15); ( 2) by demonstration (verses 17, 18); (3) by example (a) in the case of the demons (verse 19) ; (b) in the case of Abraham (Yerses 21-23); (4) by inspired affirmation (verses 14-26); (5) by an appeal to common sense (verse 24). "Ye see," (from the array of evidence presented) that it is "by works," (obedience to the commandments of the Lord Acts 10:34-35), that "a man is justified" (declared to be innocent), "and not only by faith," (not by faith only). The inference is obvious. There is no more important matter taught in the New Testament.
Justification is not by faith only! "It is by works a man is justified, and not only by faith." The allegation that Paul taught justification by faith only, and is in conflict with James is utterly false; there is a vast difference between the doctrine of justification by faith (which Paul and James both taught, Romans 5:1; James 2:20-22), and the doctrine of justification by faith only, which neither of them taught. We have seen earlier that the faith that saves is one that expresses itself in obedience to the commands of God. Faith, apart from works, is dead, barren, vain. (James 2:17; James 2:20; James 2:26.) Justification is by faith. (Romans 3:28; Romans 5:1.) This faith which justifies is either with, or without, works. If it is with works, it is not by faith only; and it blesses only when accompanied by the works which perfect it. If it is without works, salvation results from a faith that is dead. But, a faith that is dead is barren (unproductive of life whatsoever).
There is no salvation on the basis of a dead faith. A faith that can save is neither barren nor dead. But, faith, without works, is both barren and dead. It follows, therefore, that salvation is not by faith only.
Those whose doctrine it is that salvation is at the point and moment of faith, and without any additional acts of obedience, have found this passage to be exceedingly difficult to reconcile 'With their view that Paul taught justification by faith only. The methods have been many and the efforts to this end varied· and novel.
( 1) Luther, the leading light of the Reformation movement, made short work of the effort by denying, for a time at least, that the Epistle of James is worthy of a place in the sacred canon of Script11re, on the allegation that in the section which we have been considering, (James 2:14-26), its teaching conflicts with Paul, whose words in Romans 3:28, read: "We reckon therefore that a man is justified by faith apart from the works of the law," but which the fiery Reformer changed to read, ". . . a man is justified by faith alone, ... " an unwarranted and unjustified rendering without lexical support. He referred to James as a "right strawy epistle," said it had "no gospel character in it," and added, "I will not have it in my Bible in the number of the proper chief books." He admitted that "there is many a good saying in it," but he was unable to harmonize his doctrine of justification by faith only with it. The views are indeed irreconcilable; and, the stout-hearted Luther was honest enough not to attempt such. More recent theologians, while holding to the same view of justification as Luther, have attempted to reconcile the difference in the following ways:
(2) "Paul refers to the justification of a sinner; where, James regards the matter from the viewpoint of the justification of a Christian." This answer is both fanciful and false; there is no such distinction between the two New Testament writers as is here affirmed; both refer to the same passage of Scripture to establish Abraham's justification.. Paul, in Romans 4:1-5, refers to Genesis 15:6, to prove that Abraham was not justified by works. James, (2: 20-22), refers to Genesis 15:6, to prove that Abraha1n was justified by works I Abraham was justified by works, affirmed James. Abraham was not justified by works, declared Paul. By what scripture do they prove their contentions? The same scripture, Genesis 15:6.
It should be quite obvious that Paul and James have under consideration two different kinds of works. Paul, in Romans 3:28, tells us that "a man" is justified "apart from the works of the law." What law? The Law of Moses, of course. James informs us that Abraham was justified by works which perfected his faith. What particular work was alluded to? The offering of Isaac.
But, this was a commandment of God. It follows, therefore, that the works which are excluded (by Paul) from the plan of salvation are works such as the law of Moses, and the works which are included (by James) are the commandments of Christ and of God.
(3) "The justification of which James writes is before men ('Ye see .. .' verse 24), and not before God. Abraham's act justified him in the eyes of men, not God." This effort is both completely absurd and obviously false. Who, among men, saw the offering of Isaac? Not the young men who accompanied Abraham and Isaac to the place of offering; they were sent away. (Genesis 22:3; Genesis 22:5.) They were not present to see Abraham's justification in the act. No others were present save the patriarch and his son. If it is alleged that the justification came af /er the event, then it was neither at the point of faith or works!
(4) "Paul writes of true, justifying faith; whereas, James deals with a faith that is false and feigned." If so, Abraham was justified by a spurious and counterfeit faith! Desperate indeed must one be to entertain for a moment such a view. The faith of which James writes is invalid only when it is separated from works. Paul penned nothing in conflict with this view; on the contrary, he made obedience to the commands of God essential to salvation. (Romans 6:1-7; Galatians 3:26-27; 2 Thessalonians 1:7-9.) Inasmuch as both James and Paul were inspired writers, neither wrote a line in conflict with the other. All truth harmonizes. Paul, in Romans 3, 4, demonstrates that salvation is through Christ by faith and apart from the works of the law of Moses ; Jam es shows that salvation is by a faith which expresses itself in humble and unquestioning obedience to the will of the Lord. (James 2:14-26.)
Strange indeed that men would insist, in the light of this section of Scripture that salvation is by faith only; but so all denominational bodies do which deny the essentiality of water baptism. Stranger still that men who are members of the body of Christ and who accept the view that baptism sustains some relation to the plan of salvation would assert that there is some sense in which salvation is by faith only! Salvation is not by faith alone; salvation is not by works alone; the former view is that of the major Protestant denominations; the latter view is that of the Roman Catholic Church! The truth is, as illustrated in the case of Abraham (James 2:20-22), faith exercises itself with works, and in works it is perfected: "Thou seest that faith wrought with his works, and by works was faith made perfect." Legalism, does some one shout? Then let the charge be levelled at Jam es, who penned these words, and not at those of us who believe them I Highly susp1c1ous is any effort, however much piety its advocates may affect, which has, as its design, the aim to minimize any of the commandments of Christ. The same Lord which commanded faith requires baptism in water (Matthew 28:18-20) ; it is an officious intermeddling with the will of God to magnify one and minimize the other. Those who thus do are spiritual ancestors of the Pharisees who had developed the practice into a profession ! (Matthew 23 :lfI.)
(b) In The Case Of Rahab
25 And in like manner was not also Rahab the harlot justified by works,---"In like manner," means, in this instance, in the same way. Rahab affords another example of that which James, in this section of his Epistle, affirms-that justification is not by faith only, but is also dependent on acts of obedience to God's will. It is not improbable that James deliberately selected two instances from Old Testament history-Abraham and Rahab -the former from the highest ranks of the most illustrious, the second from one who had been on the lowest rung of the social ladder, to show that in neither instance was salvation by faith only, and that each perfected the faith exercised in works. Rahab was an inhabitant of Jericho, a heathen before her contact with the messengers, and it is possible that her case was cited, in addition to that of Abraham, for the further design of showing that the principle of justification is the same whether applied to those in the family especially favored of God or those out of it. We are not, of course, to assume that Rahab was a harlot at the time she was justified by works; formerly a pagan, she had lived as many pagans did, a life of loose, dissolute activity; and though she had ceased that manner of living, the identifying phrase by which she had been known, clung to her. For the details of her life, see Joshua 2:1-24.
in that she received the messengers, and sent them out another way?---This woman of the ancient past, a harlot (a prostitute, a woman who sold her body for immoral purposes), was living in Jericho, in the Jordan valley, during the conquest of Canaan by the Israelites. When Joshua sent spies into the city to obtain information on the basis of which the city was later to be besieged and taken, she received them into her house, welcomed them, hid them, protected them, and then enabled them to escape safely, having elicited from them a promise of deliverance for her loved ones, when the Israelites had taken the city. (Joshua 2:1-14.) In these actions she evidenced her faith, a faith which expressed itself in the actions above outlined. Her's was not a vain and empty faith; it busied itself in performing those actions which validated it. Hundreds of years later, the Hebrew writer. in detailing the heroic acts of faith in Israel's history, did not overlook this impressive incident, but cited it as an example of genuine faith and great courage: "By faith Rahab the harlot perished not with them that were disobedient, having received the spies in peace." (Hebrews 11:31.)
The verbs of action, in verse 25 are significant. Rahab ''received" (hupodexamene, aorist middle participle, to welcome) the messengers and "sent them out" (exbalousa, aorist active participle, to hurry away) another way. Her's was an invaluable sen·ice which she performed gladly and effectively. Thus, she, like Abraham, afforded James with another excellent example of true. justifying faith (faith expressing itself in works.) Rahab is listed in the genealogy of our Lord, having married Salmon. (Matthew 1:5.)
26 For as the body apart from the spirit is dead,---The body (soma) is the animal frame of man which houses the spirit- the immortal nature-and which is temporal, irail, subject to deterioration and decay. In death it is dissolved (2 Corinthians 5:1): it is a "tabernacle" which must be put off (2 Peter 1:13-14) : it is made from the dust of the ground (Genesis 2:7), to which it returns at death (Ecclesiastes 12:7). The word soma, translated "body" in our text, does not denote the material substance (this is the sarx, flesh, and its related substances). as much as it inillcates the composition of the flesh into an organism which, when united with the spirit, constitutes life. The "spirit'' (fmeuma) is the ''vital principle by which the body is animated·' (Thayer) : and, in this instance, refers to the immortal nature of man. The soul, not mentioned here, but often elsewhere in the sacred writings; is a generic term, the context determining its significance, in any given instance. It is used (a) to designate the whole person (Acts 2:41; 1 Peter 3:20); (b) the animal life which man possesses, and which ends in death (Psalms 78:50); (c) in contradistinction to the spirit, the intellectual nature (1 Corinthians 2:14, Greek; Hebrews 4:12; 1 Thessalonians 5:21); and (d) the spirit, the immortal nature (Acts 2:31).
The body is temporal and frail and eventually falls into the grave; the spirit (and soul, when used as a synonym of the spirit), is eternal and therefore not subject to dissolution or decay. Our bodies we receive from our earthly parents; our spirits are infused into us, and fathered for us, by God himself. (Hebrews 12:9.) Were it possible, in view of this fact, (which it is not), to prove that there is some moral taint hereditarily transmitted from parent to child (which theologians style Original Sin, the Adamic Nature, etc.,) the doctrine of Total Depravity would still not be established, because our spirits come to us directly from God, and not from our parents. Inasmuch as "like begets like" (Genesis 1:9-25, every thing brings forth after its own kind), and since God begets our spirits, they are, at birth, as pure as the source from which they spring, and become sinful only through personal transgression.
The body, "apart from the spirit," is dead. "Dead," (nekron) signifies one whose life is extinct, "one that has breathed his last, lifeless." (Thayer.) One who is dead, is therefore, destitute of life. Here, incidentally is tl1e best brief, practical definition of death (and, by implication, life) which can be formulated. What is life! It is that state or condition which obtains while the body and spirit are united. What is death? It is the resulting condition when the spirit is no longer in the body. Death is then, simply the separation of body and spirit. The body, the outward frame of man, without the spirit which animates it, is dead, lifeless, henceforth inactive.
even so faith apart from works is dead.---This is the conclusion, which inspiration draws from the foregoing premises. Faith, without works, is as lifeless as the body without the spirit. Compared here are two things, both dead. One is spiritually dead, the other is physically dead. Faith, without · works, is as destitute of life as is a fleshly body without the spirit. Separate faith and works, and the faith remaining is as lifeless as a body from which the spirit has departed. What are the works which must be joined to faith to make it alive? The commandments of the Lord. (Acts 10:34-35.) These commandments are righteousness. (Psalms 119:172.) Only those who work righteousness are acceptable to him. "Whosoever doeth not righteousness is not of God . . .. " (1 John 3:10.)
While the principles herein taught by James are of course applicable to alien sinners-those who have never obeyed the gospel- we must not assume that they are limited to such. As a matter of fact, these words were penned especially to Christians; and are designed to impress believers with the fact that their faith must evidence itself in action to be a blessing to them. Members of the church whose faith does not prompt them to faithfulness in the Lord's work, and to regular Christian activity such as consistent church attendance, liberality in giving, and personal work, are spiritual corpses, possessed of a faith which is destitute of all life.