35. Finally, if you think it right, returning to our inquiry, we ask this of you, whether
you think that all stories about the gods,4500 that is, without any exception,4501 have been
written throughout with a double meaning and sense, and in a way4502 admitting of several
interpretations; or that some parts of them are not ambiguous at all, while, on the contrary,
others have many meanings, and are enveloped in the veil of allegory which has been thrown
round them? For if the whole structure and arrangement of the narrative have been surroun-
ded with a veil of allegory from beginning to end, explain to us, tell us, what we should put
and substitute for each thing which every story says, and to what other things and meanings
we should refer4503 each. For as, to take an example, you wish Jupiter to be said instead of
the rain, Ceres for the earth, and for Libera4504 and father Dis the sinking and casting of
seed into the earth, so you ought to say what we should understand for the bull, what for
the wrath and anger of Ceres; what the word Brimo4505 means; what the anxious prayer of
Jupiter; what the gods sent to make intercession for him, but not listened to; what the cas-
trated ram; what the parts4506 of the castrated ram; what the satisfaction made with these;
what the further dealings with his daughter, still more unseemly in their lustfulness; so, in
the other story also, what the grove and flowers of Henna are; what the fire taken from Ætna,
and the torches lit with it; what the travelling through the world with these; what the Attic
country, the canton of Eleusin, the hut of Baubo, and her rustic hospitality; what the drought
of cyceon4507means, the refusal of it, the shaving and disclosure of the privy parts, the
shameful charm of the sight, and the forgetfulness of her bereavement produced by such
means. Now, if you point out what should be put in the place of all these, changing the one
for the other,4508 we shall admit your assertion; but if you can neither present another
supposition in each case, nor appeal to4509 the context as a whole, why do you make that
4500 The ms., first four edd., and Hild. read de his—“about these,” corrected in the others dîs or diis, as above.
4501 Lit., “each.”
4502 Pl.
4503 Lit., “call.”
4504 i.e., Proserpine. The readiness with which Arnobius breaks the form of the sentence should be noted.
At first the gods represent physical phenomena, but immediately after natural events are put for the gods. In
the ms. two copyists have been at work, the earlier giving Libero, which is rather out of place, and is accordingly
corrected by the later, Libera followed by LB., Oberthür, Orelli, Hild., and Oehler.
4505 The ms. reads primo. Cf. c. 20.
4506 Proles.
4507 [κυκεὼν, a draught resembling caudle. See p. 499, note 10.]
4508 Lit., “by change of things.”
4509 The ms. omits ad, supplied by Ursinus.
Chapter XXXV.
1213
Chapter XXXV.