The beginning of his accusation
was that we are ashamed of the Cross of Him Who for our sakes underwent
the Passion. Surely he does not intend to charge against us also that
we preach the doctrine of dissimilarity in essence! Why, it is rather
to those who turn aside to this opinion that the reproach belongs of
going about to make the Cross a shameful thing. For if by both parties
alike the dispensation of the Passion is held as part of the faith,
while we hold it necessary to honour, even as the Father is honoured,
the God Who was manifested by the Cross, and they find the
Passion a hindrance to glorifying the Only-begotten God equally with
the Father that begat Him, then our sophist’s charges recoil upon
himself, and in the words with which he imagines himself to be accusing
us, he is publishing his own doctrinal impiety. For it is clear that
the reason why he sets the Father above the Son, and exalts Him with
supreme honour, is this,—that in Him is not seen the shame of the
Cross: and the reason why he asseverates that the nature of the Son
varies in the sense of inferiority is this,—that the reproach of
the Cross is referred to Him alone, and does not touch the Father. And
let no one think that in saying this I am only following the general
drift of his composition, for in going through all the blasphemy of his
speech, which is there laboriously brought together, I found, in a
passage later than that before us, this very blasphemy clearly
expressed in undisguised language; and I propose to set forth, in the
orderly course of my own argument, what they have written, which runs
thus:—“If,” he says, “he can show that the God
Who is over all, Who is the unapproachable Light, was incarnate, or
could be incarnate, came under authority, obeyed commands, came under
the laws of men, bore the Cross, then let him say that the Light is
equal to the Light.” Who then is it who is ashamed of the Cross?
he who, even after the Passion, worships the Son equally with the
Father, or he who even before the Passion insults Him, not only by
ranking Him with the creation, but by maintaining that He is of
passible nature, on the ground that He could not have come to
experience His sufferings had He not had a nature capable of such
sufferings? We on our part assert that even the body in which He
underwent His Passion, by being mingled with the Divine Nature, was
made by that commixture to be that which the assuming Or
“resuming.” Cf. Book II. §8 (sup. p. 113, where
see note 7).
Nature is. So far are we from entertaining any low idea concerning the
Only-begotten God, that if anything belonging to our lowly nature was
assumed in His dispensation of love for man, we believe that even this
was transformed to what is Divine and incorruptible With S.
Gregory’s language here may be compared that of S. Athanasius
(Or. adv. Arian. iii. 53), “It was not the Wisdom,
quâ Wisdom, that ‘advanced’; but the humanity in the
Wisdom that did advance, gradually ascending above the human nature and
being made Divine (θεοποιούμενον).”;
but Eunomius makes the suffering of the Cross to be a sign of
divergence in essence, in the sense of inferiority, considering, I know
not how, the surpassing act of power, by which He was able to perform
this, to be an evidence of weakness; failing to perceive the fact that,
while nothing which moves according to its own nature is looked upon as
surprisingly wonderful, all things that overpass the limitations of
their own nature become especially the objects of admiration, and to
them every ear is turned, every mind is attentive, in wonder at the
marvel. And hence it is that all who preach the word point out the
wonderful character of the mystery in this respect,—that
“God was manifested in the flesh 1 Tim. iii.
16,
where it would appear that Gregory read θεός; not
ὅς.,” that “the Word was made flesh S. John i. 14,” that “the Light shined in
darkness S. John i. 5 (not verbally).,” “the Life tasted
death,” and all such declarations which the heralds of the faith
are wont to make, whereby is increased the marvellous character
of Him Who
manifested the superabundance of His power by means external to his own
nature. But though they think fit to make this a subject for their
insolence, though they make the dispensation of the Cross a reason for
partitioning off the Son from equality of glory with the Father, we
believe, as those “who from the beginning were eye-witnesses and
ministers of the word S. Luke i. 2” delivered to
us by the Holy Scriptures, that the God who was in the beginning,
“afterwards”, as Baruch says, “was seen upon the
earth, and conversed with men Bar. iii. 37.,” and, becoming
a ransom for our death, loosed by His own resurrection the bonds of
death, and by Himself made the resurrection a way for all flesh See
Note 2, p. 104, sup., and being on the same throne and in the same
glory with His own Father, will in the day of judgment give sentence
upon those who are judged, according to the desert of the lives they
have led. These are the things which we believe concerning Him Who was
crucified, and for this cause we cease not to extol Him exceedingly,
according to the measure of our powers, that He Who by reason of His
unspeakable and unapproachable greatness is not comprehensible by any,
save by Himself and the Father and the Holy Spirit, He, I say, was able
even to descend to community with our weakness. But they adduce this
proof of the Son’s alienation in nature from the Father, that the
Lord was manifested by the flesh and by the Cross, arguing on the
ground that the Father’s nature remained pure in impassibility,
and could not in any way admit of a community which tended to passion,
while the Son, by reason of the divergence of His nature by way of
humiliation, was not incapable of being brought to experience the flesh
and death, seeing that the change of condition was not great, but one
which took place in a certain sense from one like state to another
state kindred and homogeneous, because the nature of man is created,
and the nature of the Only-begotten is created also. Who then is fairly
charged with being ashamed of the Cross? he who speaks basely of it Reading αὐτοῦ (for
which Oehler cites good ms. authority),
for ἑαυτοῦ (the
reading of his text, as well as of the Paris editions)., or he who contends for its more exalted
aspect? I know not whether our accuser, who thus abases the God Who was
made known upon the Cross, has heard the lofty speech of Paul, in what
terms and at what length he discourses with his exalted lips concerning
that Cross. For he, who was able to make himself known by miracles so
many and so great, says, “God forbid that I should glory in
anything else, than in the Cross of Christ Gal. vi. 14 (not
verbally)..” And to the Corinthians he says that
the word of the Cross is “the power of God to them that are in a
state of salvation Cf. 1 Cor. i. 18.” To the
Ephesians, moreover, he describes by the figure of the Cross the power
that controls and holds together the universe, when he expresses a
desire that they may be exalted to know the exceeding glory of this
power, calling it height, and depth, and breadth, and length Cf. Eph. iii. 18, speaking of the several projections we
behold in the figure of the Cross by their proper names, so that he
calls the upper part “height,” and that which is below, on
the opposite side of the junction, “depth,” while by the
name “length and breadth” he indicates the cross-beam
projecting to either side, that hereby might be manifested this great
mystery, that both things in heaven, and things under the earth, and
all the furthest bounds of the things that are, are ruled and sustained
by Him Who gave an example of this unspeakable and mighty power in the
figure of the Cross. But I think there is no need to contend further
with such objections, as I judge it superfluous to be anxious about
urging arguments against calumny when even a few words suffice to show
the truth. Let us therefore pass on to another charge.