12. Oh that in such circumstances the question debated among the servants of God were
which of their number should remain, that the Church might not be left destitute by all
fleeing from danger, and which of their number should flee, that the Church might not left
destitute by all perishing in the danger. Such a contest will arise among the brethren who
are all alike glowing with love and satisfying the claims of love. And if it were in any case
impossible otherwise to terminate the debate, it appears to me that the persons who are to
remain and who are to flee should be chosen by lot. For those who say that they, in preference
to others, ought to flee, will appear to be chargeable either with cowardice, as persons un-
willing to face impending danger, or with arrogance, as esteeming their own lives more ne-
cessary to be preserved for the good of the Church than those of other men. Again, perhaps,
those who are better will be the first to choose to lay down their lives for the brethren; and
so preservation by flight will be given to men whose life is less valuable because their skill
in counselling and ruling the Church is less; yet these, if they be pious and wise, will resist
the desires of men in regard to whom they see, on the one hand, that it is more important
for the Church that they should live, and on the other hand, that they would rather lose
their lives than flee from danger. In this case, as it is written, “the lot causeth contentions
to cease, and parteth between the mighty;”2993 for, in difficulties of this kind, God judges
better than men, whether it please Him to call the better among His servants to the reward
of suffering, and to spare the weak, or to make the weak stronger to endure trials, and then
to withdraw them from this life, as persons whose lives could not be so serviceable to the
Church as the lives of the others who are stronger than they. If such an appeal to the lot be
made, it will be, I admit, an unusual proceeding, but if it is done in any case, who will dare
to find fault with it? Who but the ignorant or the prejudiced will hesitate to praise with the
approbation which it deserves? If, however, the use of the lot is not adopted because there
581
is no precedent for such an appeal, let it by all means be secured that the Church be not,
through the flight of any one, left destitute of that ministry which is more especially necessary
and due to her in the midst of such great dangers. Let no one hold himself in such esteem
because of apparent superiority in any grace as to say that he is more worthy of life than
others, and therefore more entitled to seek safety in flight. For whoever thinks this is too
self-satisfied, and whoever utters this must make all dissatisfied with him.
13. There are some who think that bishops and clergy may, by not fleeing but remaining
in such dangers, cause the people to be misled, because, when they see those who are set
over them remaining, this makes them not flee from danger. It is easy for them, however,
to obviate this objection, and the reproach of misleading others, by addressing their congreg-
ations, and saying: “Let not the fact that we are not fleeing from this place be the occasion
of misleading you, for we remain here not for our own sakes but for yours, that we may
2993 Prov. xviii. 18.
1229
To Honoratus