Now was the opportunity of Valens. He saw the
capabilities of the Homœan compromise, as yet embodied in no
creed, and resolved to try it: and his experiment was not unsuccessful.
All parties alike seem to have agreed upon the necessity for a council of the whole
Church (on the origin of the proposal, and for other details, see p.
448). But Valens was determined what the result of the council must be.
Accordingly he prevailed on the Emperor to divide it, the Western Synod
to meet at Ariminum, the Eastern at ‘Rocky Seleucia,’ a
mountain fortress in Cilicia where there happened to be plenty of
troops. The management of the latter was entrusted to Acacius; at
Rimini Valens would be present in person. In event of the two synods
differing, a delegation of ten bishops from each was to meet at Court
and settle the matter. The Creed to be adopted had also to be arranged
beforehand, and for this purpose, to his great discredit, Basil of
Ancyra entered into a conference (along with Mark of Arethusa and
certain colleagues) with Valens, George of Alexandria, and others of
like mind. The result was the ‘Dated Creed’ (May 22, 359)
drawn by Mark, prohibiting the word οὐσία (in a gentler tone than
that of the creed of Valens in 357), but containing the definition
ὅμοιον κατὰ
πάντα (‘as also the Scriptures
teach,’ see above, on Cyril, p. xlix.), words which Valens and
Ursacius sought to suppress. But Constantius insisted on their
retention, and Basil emphasised his subscription by a strongly-worded
addition. Moreover in conjunction with George of Laodicea he drew up a
memorandum (Epiph. 72, 12–22) vindicating the term οὐσία as implied in Scripture,
insisting on the absolute essential likeness of the Son to the Father,
except in respect of the Incarnation, and repudiating the idea that
ἀγεννησία is the
essential notion of Godhead. Such a protest was highly significant as
an approach to the Nicene position, but Basil must have felt its
inefficiency for the purpose in hand. Had the creed been anything but a
surrender of principle on his part, no explanatory memoranda would have
been needed.