Eusebius here makes the reign of Augustus begin with the death of
Julius Cæsar (as Josephus does in chap. 9, §1, below), and he
puts the birth of Christ therefore into the year 752 U.C. (2 b.c.), which agrees with Clement of
Alexandria’s Strom. I. (who gives the twenty-eighth year
after the conquest of Egypt as the birth-year of Christ), with
Epiphanius, Hær. LI. 22, and Orosius, Hist. I. 1.
Eusebius gives the same date also in his Chron. (ed.
Schœne, II. p. 144). Irenæus, III. 25, and Tertullian,
Adv. Jud. 8, on the other hand, give the forty-first year of
Augustus, 751 U.C. (3 b.c.). But all these
dates are certainly too late. The true year of Christ’s birth has
always been a matter of dispute. But it must have occurred before the
death of Herod, which took place in the spring of 750 U.C. (4 b.c.). The most widely accepted opinion is that
Christ was born late in the year 5, or early in the year 4 b.c., though some scholars put the date back as far as 7
b.c.
The time of the year is also
uncertain, the date commonly accepted in the occident (Dec. 25th)
having nothing older than a fourth century tradition in its favor. The
date accepted by the Greek Church (Jan. 6th) rests upon a somewhat
older tradition, but neither day has any claim to
reliability.
For a full and excellent
discussion of this subject, see the essay of Andrews in his Life of
our Lord, pp. 1–22. See, also, Schaff’s Church
Hist. I. p. 98 sq.