On Bk. V. Introd. § I (note 3, continued).
The
Successors of Antoninus Pius
.
Antoninus Pius was succeeded in
161 by his adopted sons, Marcus Aurelius Antoninus Verus and Lucius
Ceionius Ælius Aurelius Commodus Antoninus. Upon his accession to
the throne the former transferred his name Verus to the latter, who was
thenceforth called Lucius Aurelius Verus. In his
Chronicle
Eusebius keeps these two princes distinct, but in his
History
he
falls into sad confusion in regard to them, and this confusion has
drawn upon him the severe censure of all his critics. He knew of
course, as every one did, that Antoninus Pius had two successors. In
Bk. IV. chap. 14, § 10, he states this directly, and gives the
names of the successors as “Marcus Aurelius Verus, who was also
called Antoninus,” and “Lucius.” From that point on
he calls the former of these princes simply Antoninus Verus, Antoninus,
or Verus, dropping entirely the name Marcus Aurelius. In Bk. IV. chap.
18, § 2, he speaks of the emperor “whose times we are now
recording,” that is, the successor of Antoninus Pius, and calls
him Antoninus Verus. In Bk. V. Introd. § I he refers to the same
emperor as Antoninus Verus, and in Bk. V. chap. 4, § 3, and chap.
9, he calls him simply Antoninus, while in Bk. IV. chap. 13, § 8,
he speaks of him as the “Emperor Verus.” The death of this
Emperor Antoninus is mentioned in Bk. V. chap. 9, and it is there said
that he reigned nineteen years and was then succeeded by Commodus. It
is evident that in all these passages he is referring to the emperor
whom we know as Marcus Aurelius, but to whom he gives that name only
once, when he records his accession to the empire. On the other hand,
in Bk. V. chap. 5, § 1, Eusebius speaks of Marcus Aurelius
Cæsar and expressly distinguishes him from the Emperor Antoninus,
to whom he has referred at the close of the previous chapter, and makes
him the brother of that emperor. Again, in the same chapter, § 6,
he calls this Marcus Aurelius Cæsar, just referred to, the
“Emperor Marcus,” still evidently distinguishing him from
the Emperor Antoninus. In this chapter, therefore, he thinks of Marcus
Aurelius as the younger of the two sons left by Antoninus Pius; that
is, he identifies him with the one whom we call Lucius Verus, and whom
he himself calls Lucius in Bk. IV. chap. 14 § 10. Eusebius thus
commits a palpable error. How are we to explain it?
The explanation seems to me to
lie in the circumstance that Eusebius attempted to reconcile the
tradition that Marcus Aurelius was not a persecutor with the fact known
to him as a historian, that the emperor who succeeded Antoninus Pius
was. It was the common belief in the time of Eusebius, as it had been
during the entire preceding century, that all the good emperors had
been friendly to the Christians, and that only the bad
emperors had persecuted.
Of course, among the good emperors was included the philosophical
Marcus Aurelius (cf. e.g. Tertullian’s
Apol
. chap. 5, to
which Eusebius refers in Bk. V. chap. 5). It was of Marcus Aurelius,
moreover, that the story of the Thundering Legion was told (see
ibid
.). But Eusebius was not able to overlook the fact that
numerous martyrdoms occurred during the reign of the successor of
Antoninus Pius. He had the documents recording the terrible persecution
at Lyons and Vienne; he had an apology of Melito, describing the
hardships which the Christians endured under the same emperor (see Bk.
IV. chap. 26). He found himself, as an historian, face to face with two
apparently contradictory lines of facts. How was the contradiction to
be solved? He seems to have solved it by assuming that a confusion of
names had taken place, and that the prince commonly known as Marcus
Aurelius, whose noble character was traditional, and whose friendship
to the Christians he could not doubt, was the younger, not the older of
the two brothers, and therefore not responsible for the numerous
martyrdoms which took place after the death of Antoninus Pius. And yet
he is not consistent with himself even in his History; for he gives the
two brothers their proper names when he first mentions them, and says
nothing of an identification of Marcus Aurelius with Lucius. It is not
impossible that the words Marcus Aurelius, which are used nowhere else
of the older brother, are an interpolation; but for this there is no
evidence, and it may be suggested as more probable that at the time
when this passage was written the solution of the difficulty which he
gives distinctly in Bk. V. chap. 5 had not yet occurred to him. That he
should be able to fancy that Marcus Aurelius was identical with Lucius
is perhaps not strange when we remember how much confusion was caused
in the minds of other writers besides himself by the perplexing
identity of the names of the various members of the Antonine family. To
the two successors of Antoninus Pius, the three names, Aurelius, Verus,
and Antoninus, alike belonged. It is not surprising that Eusebius
should under the circumstances think that the name Marcus may also have
belonged to the younger one. This supposition would seem to him to find
some confirmation in the fact that the most common official designation
of the older successor of Antoninus Pius was not Marcus Aurelius, but
Antoninus simply, or M. Antoninus. The name Marcus Aurelius or Marcus
was rather a popular than an official designation. Even in the
Chronicle
there seems to be a hint that Eusebius thought of a
possible distinction between Antoninus the emperor and Marcus, or
Marcus Aurelius; for while he speaks of the “Emperor
Antoninus” at the beginning of the passages in which he recounts
the story of the Thundering Legion (year of Abr. 2188), he says at the
close:
literæ quoque exstant Marci regis
(the
M. Aureli
gravissimi imperatoris
of Jerome looks like a later expansion of
the simpler original)
quibus testatur copias suas iamiam perituras
Christianorum precibus servatas esse
. But even when he had reached
the solution pointed out, Eusebius did not find himself clear of
difficulties; for his sources put the occurrence of the Thundering
Legion after the date at which the younger brother was universally
supposed to have died, and it was difficult on still other grounds to
suppose the prince named Marcus Aurelius already dead in 169 (the date
given by Eusebius himself in his
Chronicle
for the death of
Lucius). In this emergency he came to the conclusion that there must be
some mistake in regard to the date of his death, and possessing no
record of the death of Marcus Aurelius as distinct from Antoninus, he
simply passed it by without mention.
That Eusebius in accepting such
a lame theory showed himself altogether too much under the influence of
traditional views cannot be denied; but when we remember that the
tradition that Marcus Aurelius was not a persecutor was supported by
writers whose honesty and accuracy he could never have thought of
questioning, as well as by the very nature of the case, we must, while
we smile at the result, at least admire his effort to solve the
contradiction which he, as an historian, felt more keenly than a less
learned man, unacquainted with the facts on the other side, would have
done.