if he meant that the Roman Church had never known that the Bishop of Constantinople
took the second place in the Church, and the first in the East, since his legates, whose conduct
he entirely approves, had just themselves authorized it as a thing beyond dispute, and Euse-
bius of Dorylæum maintained that St. Leo himself had proved it.” The simple fact is, that,
exceedingly unwilling as the Bishops of Rome were to sanction it, from this time, 381, to
say the least, the Bishop of Constantinople appears uniformly as first bishop of the East.
Cardinal Baronius in his Annals (a.d. 381, n. 35, 36) has disputed the genuineness of
this Canon! As already mentioned it is found in the Corpus Juris Canonici, Decretum, Pars
I., Dist. XXII, c. iij. The note added to this in Gratian reads as follows:
Note in Gratian’s “Decretum.”
This canon is of the number of those which the Apostolic See of Rome did not at first
nor for long years afterwards receive. This is evident from Epistle LI. (or LIII.) of Pope Leo
I. to Anatolius of Constantinople and from several other of his letters. The same thing also
is shewn by two letters of Leo IX.’s, the one against the presumptuous acts of Michael and
Leo (cap. 28) and the other addressed to the same Michael. But still more clearly is this seen
from the letter of Blessed Gregory (xxxj., lib. VI.) to Eulogius of Alexandria and Anastasius
of Antioch, and from the letter of Nicholas I. to the Emperor Michel which begins “Pro-
posueramus.” However, the bishops of Constantinople, sustained by the authority of the
Emperors, usurped to themselves the second place among the patriarchs, and this at length
was granted to them for the sake of peace and tranquillity, as Pope Innocent III. declares
(in cap. antiqua de privileg.).232
This canon Dionysius Exiguus appends to Canon 2, and dropping 5, 6, and 7 he has but
three canons of this Synod.
232 For some reason this canon does not seem to be any more acceptable to modern champions of the Papacy
than it was to the Church of Rome fifteen hundred years ago. I give as a sample of this the following from a recent
Roman Catholic writer: “The decree which goes by the name of the Third Canon of Constantinople was the
germ of the successful mendacity of the arch-rebel Photius.” (Rivington. The Prim. Ch., p. 263). The phraseology
seems to suggest warm discontent at the canon.
352
Canon III.