3. The course of our argument,
however, has diverged to another point: for the subject of our
speculation was not the fact that the energy of mind is of more dignity
among the attributes we conceive in man than the material element of
his being, but the fact that the mind is not confined to any one part
of us, but is equally in all and through all, neither surrounding
anything without, nor being enclosed within anything: for these phrases are
properly applied to casks or other bodies that are placed one inside
the other; but the union of the mental with the bodily presents a
connection unspeakable and inconceivable,—not being within
it (for the incorporeal is not enclosed in a body), nor yet surrounding
it without (for that which is incorporeal does not include It
does not seem of much consequence whether we read περιλαμβάνεται
with Forbes and the mss., and
treat it as of the middle voice, or περιλαμβάνει
τι with the Paris Editt. The
reading περιλαμβάνεται, taken passively, obscures the sense of the
passage. anything), but the mind approaching our
nature in some inexplicable and incomprehensible way, and coming into
contact with it, is to be regarded as both in it and around it, neither
implanted in it nor enfolded with it, but in a way which we cannot
speak or think, except so far as this, that while the nature prospers
according to its own order, the mind is also operative; but if any
misfortune befalls the former, the movement of the intellect halts
correspondingly.