THE PERPETUAL VIRGINITY OF BLESSED MARY. 343
deed my sister, on the father's side, not on the
mother's, " that is to say, she was the daugh- ter of his brother, not of his sister. Other-
wise, what are we to say of Abraham, a just
man, taking to wife the daughter of his own
father ? Scripture, in relating the history of
the men of early times, does not outrage our
ears by speaking of the enormity in express
terms, but prefers to leave it to be inferred by
the reader : and God afterwards gives to the
prohibition the sanction of the law, and threat-
ens,1 " He who takes his sister, born of his father, or of his mother, and beholds her
nakedness, hath commited abomination, he
shall be utterly destroyed. He hath uncovered
his sister's nakedness, he shall bear his sin." . 18. There are things which, in your extreme
ignorance, you had never read, and therefore
you* neglected the whole range of Scripture and employed your madness in outraging the
Virgin, like the man in the story who being
unknown to everybody and finding that he
could devise no good deed by which to gain
renown, burned the temple of Diana : and
when no one revealed the sacrilegious acf, it
is said that he himself went up and down
proclaiming that he was the man who had
applied the fire. The rulers of Ephesus were
curious to know what made him do this thing,
whereupon he replied that if he could not have
fame for good deeds, all men should give him
credit for bad ones. Grecian history relates the
incident. But you do worse. You have set on
fire the temple of the Lord's body, you have defiled the sanctuary of the Holy Spirit from
which you are determined to make a team of
four brethren and a heap of sisters come forth.
In a word, joining in the chorus of the Jews
you say, a " Is not this the carpenter's son ? is not his mother called Mary ? and his brethren
James, and Joseph, and Simon, and Judas?
and his sisters, are fhey not all with us ? The word all would not be used if there were not
a crowd of them." Pray tell me, who, before you appeared, was acquainted with this blas-
phemv ? who thought the theory worth two-
pence ? You have gained your desire, and are
become notorious by crime. For myself who
am your opponent, although we live in the
''same city, I don't know, as the saying is, whether you are white or black. I pass over
faults of diction which abound in every book
you write. I say not a word about your absurd introduction. Good heavens ! I do not ask
for eloquence, since, having none yourself, you
applied for a supply of it to your brother Crate-
rius. I do not ask for grace of style, I look
for purity of soul : for with Christians it is
1 Lev. xviii. 9.
» S. Matt. xiii. 55 : S. Mark vi. 3. ' That is, Rome.
the greatest of solecisms and of vices of style
to introduce anything base either in word or
action. I am come to the conclusion of my
argument. I will deal with you as though I
had as yet prevailed nothing ; and you will
find yourself on the horns of a dilemma. It
is clear that our Lord's brethren bore the name in the same way that Joseph was called his
father : ' " I and thy father sought thee sor-
rowing." It was His mother who said this, not the Jews. The Evangelist himself relates that
His father and His mother were marvelling at
the things which were spoken concerning Him,
and there are similar passages which we have
already quoted in which Joseph and Mary are
called his parents. Seeing that you have been
foolish enough to persuade yourself that the
Greek manuscripts are corrupt, you will per-
haps plead the diversity of readings. I there-
fore come to the Gospel of John, and there it
is plainly written,3 " Philip findeth Nathanael, and saith unto him, We have found him of
whom Moses in the law, and the prophets did
write, Jesus of Nazareth, the son of Joseph." You will certainly find this in your manu-
script. Now tell me, how is Jesus the son of
Joseph when it is clear that He was begotten
of the Holy Ghost ? Was Joseph His true
father ? Dull as you are, you will not venture
to say that. Was he His reputed father ? If
so, let the same rule be applied to them when
they are called brethren, that you apply to
Joseph when he is called father.
19. Now that I have cleared the rocks and
shoals I must spread sail and make all speed
to reach his epilogue. Feeling himself to be
a smatterer, he there produces Tertullian as a
witness and quotes the words of Victorinus
bishop of 'Petavium. Of Tertullian I say no more than that he did not belong to the
Church. But as regards Victorinus, I assert
what has already been proved from the Gospel
— that he spoke of the brethren of the Lord
not as being sons of Mary, but brethren in the
sense I have explained, that is to say, brethren
in point of kinship not by nature. We are,
however, spending our strength on trifles, and,
leaving the fountain of truth, are following the
tiny streams of opinion. Might I not array
against you the whole series of ancient writers ?
Ignatius, Polycarp, Irenoeus, Justin Martyr,
and many other apostolic and eloquent men,
who against Ebion, Theodotus of Byzantium,
and Valentinus, held these same views, and
wrote volumes replete with wisdom. If you
had ever read what they wrote, you would be
a wiser man. But I think it better to reply
1 S. Luke i. 18.
' S. John i. 45-
3 That is, Pettau in Upper Pannonia. See Jerome, De Vir. III.
7-*.