Sherlock’s work
against Owen was entitled, “A Discourse concerning the
Knowledge of Jesus Christ, and on Union and Communion with Him,”
etc. Owen confines himself, in his reply,
to an exposure of the misrepresentations in which Sherlock had indulged. The latter, for example, sought to
fix on the Puritan divine the doctrine, that the knowledge of divine things
was to be obtained from the person of Christ, apart from the truth as
revealed in the Scriptures. Our author successfully vindicates himself
from this charge, and repudiates other sentiments equally mystical, and
ascribed to him with equal injustice. The views of Sherlock, on the points at issue, have been termed, “a
confused mass of Socinianized Arminianism.” Owen evinces a strength of feeling, in some parts of his
“Vindication,” which may be accounted for on the ground that he resented
the attack as part of a systematic effort made at this time to destroy his
standing and reputation as an author. In the main, there is a dignity in
his statements which contrasts well with the wayward petulance of his
antagonist; and occasionally the reader will find a vein of quiet and
skilful irony, in the way in which he disposes of the crude views of Sherlock.