I. When we consider the
character of his great forerunner, and the kind of task which Gregory
himself undertook, the first part of this question is easily answered.
When Christian doctrine had to be set forth philosophically, so as to
be intelligible to any cultivated mind of that time (to reconcile Greek
philosophy with Christian doctrine was a task which Gregory never
dreamed of attempting), the example and leader in such an attempt was
Origen; he occupied as it were the whole horizon. He was the founder of
theology; the very vocabulary of it, which is in use now, is of his
devising. So that Gregory’s language must have had, necessarily,
a close connexion with that of the great interpreter and apologist, who
had explained to his century the same truths which Gregory had to
explain to his: this must have been the case even if his mind had not
been as spiritual and idealizing as Origen’s. But in some
respects it will be seen Gregory is even more an idealist than Origen
himself. Alike, then, from purpose and tradition as from sympathy he
would look back to Origen. Though a gulf was between them, and, since
the Council of Nicæa, there were some things that could come no
more into controversy, Gregory saw, where the Church had not spoken,
with the same eyes as Origen: he uses the same keys as he did for the
problems which Scripture has not solved; he uses the same great weapon
of allegory in making the letter of Scripture give up the spiritual
treasures. It could not have been otherwise when the whole Christian
religion, which Gregory was called on to defend as a philosophy, had
never before been systematically so defended but by Origen; and this
task, the same for both, was presented to the same type of mind, in the
same intellectual atmosphere. It would have been strange indeed if
Gregory had not been a pupil at least (though he was no blind follower)
of Origen.