“Is the celibate an Apostolic ordinance?
Bickel affirmed that it is, and Funk denied it in 1878. To-day
[1896] canonists commonly admit that one cannot prove the existence of
any formal precept, either divine or apostolic, which imposes the
celibate upon the clergy, and that all the texts, whether taken out of
Holy Scripture or from the Fathers, on this subject contain merely a
counsel, and not a command.” “In the Fourth Century a
great number of councils forbade bishops, priests, and deacons to live
in the use of marriage with their lawful wives.…But there does
not appear to have been any disposition to declare by law as invalid
the marriages of clerics in Holy Orders. In the Fifth and Sixth
Centuries the law of the celibate was observed by all the Churches of
the West, thanks to the Councils and to the Popes.”
“In the Seventh and down to the end of the Tenth
Century, It is curious that
this is just four centuries, the same length of time as from the
Reformation. as a matter of fact
the law of celibacy was little observed in a great part of the Western
Church, but as a matter of law the Roman Pontiffs and the Councils were
constant in their proclamation of its obligation.” By the
canonical practice of the unreformed West, the reception of Holy Orders
is an impedimentum dirimens matrimonii, which renders any
marriage subsequently contracted not only illicit but absolutely
null. On this diriment impediment the same Roman Catholic writer
says: “The diriment impediment of Holy Orders is of
ecclesiastical obligation and not of divine, and consequently the
Church can dispense it. This is the present teaching which is in
opposition to that of the old schools.”