being ‘Above every name236’; which is granted to the Only-begotten also, because “all that
the Father hath is the Son’s.” The orthodox theory allows these words, I mean “Ungenerate,”
“Endless,” to be indicative of God’s eternity, but not of His being; so that “Ungenerate”
means that no source or cause lies beyond Him, and “Endless” means that His kingdom
will be brought to a standstill in no end. “Thou art the same,” the prophet says, “and Thy
years shall not fail237,” showing by “art” that He subsists out of no cause, and by the words
following, that the blessedness of His life is ceaseless and unending.
But, perhaps, some one amongst even very religious people will pause over these invest-
igations of ours upon God’s eternity, and say that it will be difficult from what we have said
for the Faith in the Only-begotten to escape unhurt. Of two unacceptable doctrines, he will
say, our account238 must inevitably be brought into contact with one. Either we shall make
out that the Son is Ungenerate, which is absurd; or else we shall deny Him Eternity altogether,
a denial which that fraternity of blasphemers make their specialty. For if Eternity is charac-
terized by having no beginning and end, it is inevitable either that we must be impious and
deny the Son Eternity, or that we must be led in our secret thoughts about Him into the
idea of Ungeneracy. What, then, shall we answer? That if, in conceiving of the Father before
the Son on the single score of causation, we inserted any mark of time before the subsistence
of the Only-begotten, the belief which we have in the Son’s eternity might with reason be
said to be endangered. But, as it is, the Eternal nature, equally in the case of the Father’s and
the Son’s life, and, as well, in what we believe about the Holy Ghost, admits not of the thought
that it will ever cease to be; for where time is not, the “when” is annihilated with it. And if
100
the Son, always appearing with the thought of the Father, is always found in the category
of existence, what danger is there in owning the Eternity of the Only-begotten, Who “hath
neither beginning of days, nor end of life239.” For as He is Light from Light, Life from Life,
Good from Good, and Wise, Just, Strong, and all else in the same way, so most certainly is
He Eternal from Eternal.
But a lover of controversial wrangling catches up the argument, on the ground that such
a sequence would make Him Ungenerate from Ungenerate. Let him, however, cool his
combative heart, and insist upon the proper expressions, for in confessing His ‘coming from
the Father’ he has banished all ideas of Ungeneracy as regards the Only-begotten; and there
236 Philip. ii. 9. ὄνομα τὸ ὑπὲρ πᾶν ὄνομα.
237 Psalm cii. 27.
238 Adopting ὁ λόγος from the Venice Cod. (ἑνὶ πάντως ὁ λόγος συνενεχθήσεται). The verb cannot be im-
personal: and τις above, the only available nominative, does not suit the sense very well. Gregory constructs this
scheme of Opposition after the analogy of Logical Opposition. Beginning is not so opposed to Beginning-less,
as it is to Ending, because with the latter there is no half-way, i.e. no word of definition in common.
239 Heb. vii. 3.
190
Explanation of 'Ungenerate,' and a 'study' of Eternity.