gustine, who was especially obnoxious to them, when making honorable mention at any
time of the champions of the faith, but he denounces his doctrine, though under a misrep-
resentation of it, as one of the forms of that novel error which he reprobates.8 Indeed,
whoever will compare what he says in § 70 of the heresy which he describes but forbears to
name, with Prosper’s account of the charges brought against Augustine by certain Semipela-
gian clergymen of Marseilles,9 will have little doubt that Vincentius and they had the same
128
teacher in view, and were of the same mind with regard to his teaching. Be this however as
it may, when it is considered that the monks of Lérins, in common with the general body
of the churchmen of Southern Gaul, were strenuous upholders of Semipelagianism, it will
not be thought surprising that Vincentius should have been suspected of at least a leaning
in that direction. Tillemont, who forbears to express himself decidedly, but evidently inclines
to that view, says “L’opinion qui le condamne et l’abandonne aux Semipelagiens passe
aujourd’hui pour la plus commune parmi les savans.”10
It has been matter of question whether Vincentius is to be credited with the authorship
of the “Objectiones Vincentianæ,” a collection of Sixteen Inferences alleged to be deducible
from St. Augustine’s writings, which has come down to us in Prosper’s Reply.
Its date coincides so nearly with that of the Commonitory as to preclude all doubt as to
the identity of authorship on that score,11 and it must be confessed that its animus and that
of the 70th and 86th sections of the Commonitory are too much in keeping to make it difficult
to believe that both are from the same pen.
Vincentius’s object in the following treatise is to provide himself, as he states, with a
general rule whereby to distinguish Catholic truth from heresy; and he commits what he
has learnt, he adds, to writing, that he may have it by him for reference as a Commonitory,
or Remembrancer, to refresh his memory.
This rule, in brief, is the authority of Holy Scripture. By that all questions must be tried
in the first instance. And it would be abundantly sufficient, but that, unfortunately, men
differ in the interpretation of Holy Scripture. The rule, therefore, must be supplemented by
an appeal to that sense of Holy Scripture which is supported by universality, antiquity, and
consent: by universality, when it is the faith of the whole Church; by antiquity, when it is
that which has been held from the earliest times; by consent, when it has been the acknow-
8 Cardinal Noris does not hesitate to say of him, “Non modo Semipelagianum se prodit, sed disertis verbis
Augustini discipulos tanquam hæreticos traducit.”—Historia Pelagiana, p. 245. See below, Appendix II.
9 See Prosper’s letter to Augustine in Augustine’s works, Ep. 225, Tom. ii. Ed. Paris, 1836, etc.
10 T. xv. p. 146.
11 The Objectiones Vincentianæ must have been published at some time between the publication of St. Au-
gustine’s Antipelagian Treatises and the death of Prosper. They are to be found in Prosper’s Reply, contained
in St. Augustine’s works, Appendix, Tom. x. coll. 2535. et seq. Paris, 1836, etc.
299
Introduction.