are in no wise contaminated by the bad in such communion; answer me, therefore, why did
ye break the bond?
9. Or is it perhaps that schismatics, when received without baptism, bring no infection,
but that it is brought by those who deliver up the sacred books?1229 For that there were
traditors of your number is proved by the clearest testimony of history. And if you had then
brought true evidence against those whom you were accusing, you would have proved your
cause before the unity of the whole world, so that you would have been retained whilst they
were shut out. And if you endeavored to do this, and did not succeed, the world is not to
blame, which trusted the judges of the Church rather than the beaten parties in the suit;
whilst, if you would not urge your suit, the world again is not to blame, which could not
condemn men without their cause being heard. Why, then, did you separate yourselves
from the innocent? You cannot defend the sacrilege of your schism. But this I pass over.
But so much I say, that if the traditors could have defiled you, who were not convicted by
you, and by whom, on the contrary, you were beaten, much more could the sacrilege of
schismatics and heretics, received into the Church, as you maintain, without baptism, have
defiled Cyprian. Yet he did not separate himself. And inasmuch as the Church continued
to exist, it is clear that it could not be defiled. Wherefore, then, did you separate yourselves,
I do not say from the innocent, as the facts proved them, but from the traditors, as they were
never proved to be? Are the sins of traditors, as I began to say, heavier than those of schis-
matics? Let us not bring in deceitful balances, to which we may hang what weights we will
and how we will, saying to suit ourselves, "This is heavy and this is light;" but let us bring
forward the sacred balance out of holy Scripture, as out of the Lord’s treasure-house, and
let us weigh them by it, to see which is the heavier; or rather, let us not weigh them for
ourselves, but read the weights as declared by the Lord. At the time when the Lord showed,
by the example of recent punishment, that there was need to guard against the sins of olden
days, and an idol was made and worshipped, and the prophetic book was burned by the
wrath of a scoffing king, and schism was attempted, the idolatry was punished with the
sword,1230 the burning of the book by slaughter in war and captivity in a foreign land,1231
schism by the earth opening, and swallowing up alive the leaders of the schism while the
rest were consumed with fire from heaven.1232 Who will now doubt that that was the worse
crime which received the heavier punishment? If men coming from such sacrilegious
company, without baptism, as you maintain, could not defile Cyprian, how could those
defile you who were not convicted but supposed betrayers of the sacred books?1233 For if
1229 Traditores sanctorum librorum.
1230 Ex. xxxii.
1231 Jer. xxxvi.
1232 Num. xvi.
1233 Non convicti sed conficti traditores.
738
Chapter 6