Compare Cyprian’s epistle to Quintus concerning the baptism
of heretics (Ep. 70, al. 71). Cyprian there takes the
position stated here, that those who have been baptized in the Church
and have afterward gone over to heresy and then returned again to the
Church are not to be re-baptized, but to be received with the laying on
of hands only. This of course does not at all invalidate the position
of Cyprian and the others who re-baptized heretics, for they baptized
heretics not because they had been heretics, but because they had not
received true baptism, nor indeed any baptism at all, which it was
impossible, in their view, for a heretic to give. They therefore
repudiated (as Cyprian does in the epistle referred to) the term
re-baptism, denying that they re-baptized anybody.