Thus it is then that Eunomius
brings the truth to light for us as the result of his scientific
attack. And we for our part shall apply his argument, as we are wont to
do, for the establishment of the true doctrine, so that even by
this passage it may be clear that at every point, constrained against
their will, they advocate our view. For if, as our opponent says,
“He begat the Son at that time when He chose,” and if He
always chose that which is good, and His power coincided with His
choice, it follows that the Son will be considered as always with the
Father, Who always both chooses that which is excellent, and is able to
possess what He chooses. And if we are to reduce his next words also to
truth, it is easy for us to adapt them also to the doctrine we
hold:—“Let there be no questioning among sensible men on
this point, why He did not do so before”—for the word
“before” has a temporal sense, opposed to what is
“afterwards” and “later”: but on the
supposition that time does not exist, the terms expressing temporal
interval are surely abolished with it. Now the Lord was before times
and before ages: questioning as to “before” or
“after” concerning the Maker of the ages is useless in the
eyes of reasonable men: for words of this class are devoid of all
meaning, if they are not used in reference to time. Since then the Lord
is antecedent to times, the words “before” and
“after” have no place as applied to Him. This may perhaps
be sufficient to refute arguments that need no one to overthrow them,
but fall by their own feebleness. For who is there with so much leisure
that he can give himself up to such an extent to listen to the
arguments on the other side, and to our contention against the silly
stuff? Since, however, in men prejudiced by impiety, deceit is like
some ingrained dye, hard to wash out, and deeply burned in upon their
hearts, let us spend yet a little time upon our argument, if haply we
may be able to cleanse their souls from this evil stain. After the
utterances that I have quoted, and after adding to them, in the manner
of his teacher Prunicus, So in
Book I. πρῶτον μὲν
τῆς
Προυνίκου
σοφίας
γίνεται
μαθητὴς,
and Book XIII. p. 844 (Paris Edit.). It may be questioned whether the
phrase in Books I. and XIII., and that here, refers to a supposed
connection of Eunomius with Gnosticism. The Προύνικος
Σοφία of the Gnostics
was a “male-female,” and hence the masculine τὸν
παιδεύτην might properly be applied to it. If this point were cleared
up, we might be more certain of the meaning to be attached to the
word ὀκτάδας, which is also possibly borrowed from the Gnostic phraseology,
being akin to the form ὀγδοάδας. [On the Gnostic conception of “Prunicus,” see the
note on the subject in Harvey’s Irenæus (vol. I. p.
225), and Smith and Wace’s Dict. Chr. Biogr. s.v. On the
Gnostic Ogdoads, see Mansel’s Gnostic Heresies, pp. 152
sqq., 170 sqq., and the articles on Basilides and Valentinus in
Dict. Chr. Biogr.] some unconnected and
ill-arranged octads of insolence and abuse, he comes to the crowning
point of his arguments, and, leaving the illogical exposition of his
folly, arms his discourse once more with the weapons of dialectic, and
maintains his absurdity against us, as he imagines,
syllogistically.