“This report is very improbable, for a work full of hatred
to the Romans and of derogatory references to the emperor Caligula
could not have been read before the Roman Senate, especially when the
author was a Jew” (Closs). It is in fact quite unlikely that
Philo was in Rome during the reign of Claudius (see above, chap. 17,
note 1). The report given here by Eusebius owes its origin perhaps to
the imagination of some man who supposed that Philo was in Rome during
the reign of Claudius (on the ground of the other tradition already
referred to), and whose fancy led him to picture Philo as obtaining at
that time his revenge upon the emperor Caligula in this dramatic way.
It was not difficult to imagine that this bitterly sarcastic and vivid
work might have been intended for public reading, and it was an
attractive suggestion that the Senate might have constituted the
audience.