Chapter 2.—2. Nevertheless, I see what may still be required of me, viz., that I should
answer those plausible arguments, by which, in even earlier times, Agrippinus, or Cyprian
himself, or those in Africa who agreed with them, or any others in far distant lands beyond
the sea, were moved, not indeed by the authority of any plenary or even regionary Council,
but by a mere epistolary correspondence, to think that they ought to adopt a custom which
had no sanction from the ancient custom of the Church, and which was expressly forbidden
by the most unanimous resolution of the Catholic world in order that an error which had
begun to creep into the minds of some men, through discussions of this kind, might be
cured by the more powerful truth and universal healing power of unity coming on the side
of safety. And so they may see with what security I approach this discourse. If I am unable
to gain my point, and show how those arguments may be refuted which they bring forward
from the Council and the epistles of Cyprian, to the effect that Christ’s baptism may not be
given by the hands of heretics, I shall still remain safely in the Church, in whose communion
Cyprian himself remained with those who differed from him.
3. But if they say that the Catholic Church existed then, because there were a few, or,
if they prefer it, even a considerable number, who denied the validity of any baptism conferred
in an heretical body, and baptized all who came from thence, what then? Did the Church
not exist at all before Agrippinus, with whom that new kind of system began, at variance
with all previous custom? Or how, again after the time of Agrippinus, when, unless there
had been a return to the primitive custom, there would have been no need for Cyprian to
set on foot another Council? Was there no Church then, because such a custom as this
prevailed everywhere, that the baptism of Christ should be considered nothing but the
baptism of Christ, even though it were proved to have been conferred in a body of heretics
or schismatics? But if the Church existed even then, and had not perished through a breach
of its continuity, but was, on the contrary, holding its ground, and receiving increase in
every nation, surely it is the safest plan to abide by this same custom, which then embraced
good and bad alike in unity. But if there was then no Church in existence, because sacrile-
gious heretics were received without baptism, and this prevailed by universal custom, whence
437
has Donatus made his appearance? From what land did he spring? or from what sea did he
emerge? or from what sky did he fall? And so we, as I had begun to say, are safe in the
communion of that Church, throughout the whole extent of which the custom now prevails,
which prevailed in like manner through its whole extent before the time of Agrippinus, and
in the interval between Agrippinus and Cyprian, and whose unity neither Agrippinus nor
Cyprian ever deserted, nor those who agreed with them, although they entertained different
views from the rest of their brethren—all of them remaining in the same communion of
unity with the very men from whom they differed in opinion. But let the Donatists them-
selves consider what their true position is, if they neither can say whence they derived their
origin, if the Church had already been destroyed by the plague-spot of communion with
Chapter 2
754
Chapter 2