Unto my enforcement of the necessity of holiness from the
ends of God in election and redemption, he replies, p. 127, “The Father hath elected us to be holy, and the Son redeemed us to be holy;
but will the Father elect and the Son redeem none but those who are holy,
and reject and reprobate all others? Doth this election and redemption
suppose holiness in us, or is it without any regard to it? For if we be
elected and redeemed without any regard unto our own being holy, our
election and redemption is secure, whether we be holy or not.” Wonderful
divinity again! Election and redemption suppose holiness in us! We are
elected and redeemed with regard unto our own holiness that is,
antecedently unto our election and redemption; for holiness being the
effect and fruit of them, is that which he opposeth. Not many pages after
this, he falls into a great admiration of the catechism of the church of
England, which none blamed that I know of, as to what is contained in it.
But it were to be wished that he had been well instructed in some others,
that he might not have divulged and obtruded on the world such crude and
palpable mistakes. For this respect of redemption, at least, unto an
antecedent holiness in us (that is, antecedent unto it), is such a piece of
foppery in religion, as a man would wonder how any one could be guilty of,
who hath almost “pored out his eyes” in reading the Scripture. All the
remaining cavils of this chapter are but the effects of the like fulsome
ignorance; for out of some passages, scraped together from several parts of
my discourse (and those not only cut off from their proper scope and end,
which is not mentioned by him at all, but also mangled in their
representation), he would frame the appearance of a contradiction between
what I say on the one hand, that there is no peace with God to be obtained
by and for sinners but by the atonement that is made for them in the blood
of Jesus Christ, with the remission of sin and justification by faith which
ensue thereon (which I hope I shall not live to hear denied by the church
of England), and the necessity of holiness and fruitfulness in obedience,
to maintain in our own souls a sense of that peace with God which we have,
being justified by faith. And he who understands not the consistency of
those things, hath little reason to despise good catechisms, whatever
thoughts he hath had of his own sufficiency.