LETTER LXIX.
143
to reply. I however made a fresh onslaught
repeating my question a second time and a third. You would have taken him for Niobe
changed to stone by excessive weeping. I turned to the audience and said : It is all the
same to me, good people, whether I bind my
opponent awake or sleeping ; but it is easier to fetter a man who offers no resistance. If
those whom the apostle admits into the ranks
of the clergy are not catechumens but the
faithful, and if he who is ordained bishop is
always one of the faithful, being one of the
faithful he cannot have the faults of a cate-
chumen imputed to him. Such were the darts
I hurled at my paralysed opponent. Such the
quivering spears I cast at him. At last his
mouth opened and he vomited forth the
contents of his mind. Certainly, he blurted
out, that is the doctrine of the apostle Paul.
3. Accordingly I bring out two epistles of the
apostle, the first to Timothy, and the second
to Titus. In the first is the following passage :
" If a man desire the office of a bishop he de- sireth a good work. A bishop then must be
blameless, the husband of one wife, vigilant,
sober, of good behaviour, given to hospitality,
apt to teach, not given to wine, no striker . . .
but patient, not a brawler, not covetous ; one
that ruleth well his own house, having his chil-
dren in subjection with all gravity. (For if a
man know not how to rule his own house, how
hall he take care of the church of God ?) Not
novice lest being lifted up with pride he fall nto the condemnation of the devil. Moreover
le must have a good report of them which are
without ; lest he fall into reproach and the
nare of the devil." ' While immediately at he commencement of the epistle to Titus the
ollowing behests are laid down : " For this ause left I thee in Crete that thou shouldest
et in order the things that are wanting, and
>rdain elders in every city, as I had appointed
hee : if any be blameless, the husband of one
wife, having faithful children not accused of
iot or unruly. For a bishop must be blame-
ess as the steward of God ; not self-willed,
not soon angry, not given to wine, no striker,
not given to filthy lucre ; but a lover of hospi-
ality, a lover of good men, sober, just, holy,
emperate ; holding fast the faithful word as
he hath been taught, that he may be able by sound doctrine both to exhort and to convince
he gainsayers." 'J In both epistles command- ment is given that only monogamists should >e chosen for the clerical office whether as
)ishops or as presbyters.3 Indeed with the ancients these names were synonymous, one
alluding to the office, the other to the age of the
clergy. No one at any rate can doubt that
1 i Tim. iii. 17.
3 Rendered ' elders ' in AV.
2 Tit. i. 5-9.
the apostle is speaking only of those who have
been baptized. If therefore it in no wise preju- dices the case of one who is to be ordained
bishop that before his baptism he has not
possessed all the requisite qualifications (for it is asked what he is and not what he has
been), why should a previous marriage — the
one thing which is in itself not sinful — prove
a hindrance to his ordination ? You argue that
as his marriage was not a sin it was not done
away with at his baptism. This is news to
me indeed, that what in itself was not a sin is
to be reckoned as such. All fornication and
contamination with open vice, impiety towards
God, parricide and incest, the change of the natural use of the sexes into that which is
against nature ' and all extraordinary lusts are washed away in the fountain of Christ. Can
it be possible that the stains of marriage are
indelible, and that harlotry is judged more
leniently than honourable wedlock ? I do not,
Carterius might say, hold you to blame for
the hosts of mistresses and the troops of fav-
ourites " that you have kept ; I do not charge
you with your bloodsheddingand sow-like wal-
lowings in the mire of uncleanness : yet you are
ready to drag from her grave for my confusion
my poor wife, who has been dead long years,
and whom I married that I might be kept
from those sins into which you have fallen.
Tell this to the heathen who form the church's harvest with which she stores her granaries ;
tell this to the catechumens who seek admis-
sion to the number of the faithful ; tell them,
I say, not to contract marriages before their
baptism, not to enter upon honourable wed-
lock, but like the Scots and the Atacotti 3 and
the people of Plato's republic 4 to have com- munity of wives and no discrimination of
children, nay more, to beware of any sem-
blance even of matrimony ; lest, after they have
come to believe in Christ, He shall tell them
that those whom they have had have not been concubines or mistresses but wedded wives.
4. Let every man examine his own con-
science and let him deplore the violence he
has done to it at every period of his life ; and
then when he has brought himself to deliver a
true judgment on his own former misdeeds,
let him give ear to the chiding of Jesus :
" Thou hypocrite, first cast out the beam out of thine own eye ; and then shalt thou see
clearly to cast out the mote out of thy broth-
er's eye." 6 Truly like the scribes and phari- sees we strain out the gnat and swallow the
camel, we pay tithe of mint and anise, and we
omit the just judgment which God requires.* What parallel can be drawn between a wife
1 Cf . Rom. i. 26, 27. » Exoleti. ' A Scottish tribe, cannibals according to Jerome (Agairst
Jov. ii. 7.)
4 Bk. V. 457. 6 Matt. vii. 5. «Matt. xxiii. 23, 24, RV.