The argument of the Dialogue may be thus stated. It has
been pointed out above that Lucifer of Cagliari, who had been banished
from his see in the reign of Constantius because of his adherence to
the cause of Athanasius, had, on the announcement of toleration at the
accession of Julian (361), gone to Antioch and consecrated Paulinus a
bishop. There were then three bishops of Antioch, Dorotheus the Arian
(who had succeeded Euzoius in 376), Meletius who, though an Athanasian
in opinion, had been consecrated by Arians or Semi-Arians, and
Paulinus; besides Vitalis, bishop of a congregation of Apollinarians.
Lucifer, in the earnestness of his anti-Arian opinion, refused to
acknowledge as bishops those who had come over from Arianism, though he
accepted the laymen who had been baptized by Arian bishops. This
opinion led to the Luciferian schism, and forms the subject of the
Dialogue.