LETTER CXXIV. 241
which holy scripture threatens sinners he ex-
plains not as external punishments but as the
pangs of guilty consciences when by God's power the memory of our transgressions is set
before our eyes. " The whole crop of our sins grows up afresh from seeds which remain in
the soul, and all our dishonourable and unduti-
ful acts are again pictured before our gaze.
Thus it is the fire of conscience and the stings of remorse which torture the mind as it looks
back on former self-indulgence." And again :
" but perhaps this coarse and earthly body ought to be described as mist and darkness ;
for at the end of this world and when it be-
comes necessary to pass into another, the like
darkness will lead to the like physical birth." In speaking thus he clearly pleads for the
transmigration of souls as taught by Pythago-
ras and Plato.1 And at the end of the second
book in dealing with our perfection he has
said : " when we shall have made such prog- ress as not only to cease to be flesh or body
but perhaps also to cease to be souls our per-
fect intelligence and perception, undimmed
with any mist of passion, will discern reason-
able and intelligible substances face to face.
8. In the third book the following faulty
statements are contained. " If we once ad-
mit that, when one vessel is made to honour
and another to dishonour,11 this is due to ante- cedent causes ; why may we not revert to the
mystery of the soul and allow that it is loved
in one and hated in another because of its past
actions, before in Jacob it becomes a sup-
planter and before in Esau it is supplanted ? " And again : " the fact that souls are made some to honour and some to dishonour is to
be explained by their previous history." And
in the same place : '• on this hypothesis of mine a vessel made to honour which tails to
fulfil its object will in another world become a
vesM-1 made to dishonour ; and contrariwise a vessel which has from a previous fault been
condemned to dishonour will, if it accepts cor-
rection in this present life, become in the new
creation a vessel ' sanctified and meet for the
Master's use and prepared unto every good
work.'"4 And he immediately goes on to
say : " I believe that men who begin with small faults may become so hardened in
wickedness that, if they do not repent and
turn to better things, they must become in-
human energies ; '" and contrariwise that hos- tile and demonic beings may in course of time so far heal their wounds and check the current
of their former sins that they may attain to
the abode of the perfect. As I have often
said, in those countless and unceasing worlds
in which the soul lives and has its being some
grow worse and worse until they reach the
lowest depths of degradation ; while others in
those lowest depths grow better and better
until they reach the perfection of virtue." Thus he tries to shew that men, or rather their
souls, may become demons ; and that demons
in turn may be 'restored to the rank of angels. In the same book he writes : " this too must
be considered ; why the human soul is di-
versely acted upon now by influences of one
kind and now by influences of another." And he surmises that this is due to conduct which
has preceded birth. It is for this, he argues,
that John leaps in his mother's womb when at
Mary's salutation Elizabeth declares herself
unworthy of her notice.1 And he immediately
subjoins : " on the other hand infants that are hardly weaned are possessed with evil spirits
and become diviners and soothsayers ; ' indeed, some are indwelt from their earliest years with
the spirit of a python. Now as they have
done nothing to bring upon themselves these
visitations, one who holds that nothing hap-
pens without God's permission, and that all things are governed by His justice, cannot
suppose that God's providence has abandoned them without good reason.
9. Again, of the world he writes thus : " The belief commends itself to me that there was a
world before this world and that after it there
will be another. Do you wish to know that
after the decay of this world there will be a
new one ? Hear the words of Isaiah : ' the new heavens and the new earth which I will make
shall remain before me.'3 Do you wish to know that before the making of this world
there have previously been others ? Listen to
the Preacher who says : ' the thing which hath been, it is that which shall be ; and that
which is done is that which shall be done :
and there is no new thing under the sun. Is
there anything whereof it may be said, See,
this is new? It hath been already of old
time, which was before us.' ' A passage which proves not only that other worlds
have been but that other worlds shall be ;
not, however, simultaneously and side by
side but one after another." And he im-
mediately adds : " I hold that heaven is the abode of the deity, the true place of rest ; and that it was there that reasonable creatures
enjoyed their ancient bliss, before coming
down to a lower plane and exchanging the
invisible for the visible, they fell to the earth
and came to need material bodies. Now that
they have fallen, God the creator has made
for them bodies suitable to their surroundings ;
and has fashioned this visible world, and has
sent into it ministers to ensure the salva-
1 Phaedo, 70-77. 4 2 Tim. ii. 21.
16
a 2 Tim. ii. 20.
6 i.e. demons.
» Mai. i. 2,3. 1 Luke i. 41.
3 Isa. Ixvi. 22. 8Cf. Acts xvi. 16. A.V. margin. 4 Eccles. i. 9, 10.