The Trullan Synod and Pope Nicholas I. are further
appealed to. The former in its second canon approved of the
Sardican canons, and Pope Nicholas said of them: “omnis
Ecclesia recepit eos.” But this in no way contains a
declaration that the Synod of Sardica was ecumenical, for the canons of
many other councils also—for instance, Ancyra, Neocæsarea,
and others—were generally received without those synods
themselves being therefore esteemed ecumenical. Nay, the Trullan
Synod itself speaks for us; for had it held the Synod of Sardica to be
the second General Council, it would have placed its canons immediately
after those of Nice, whereas they are placed after the four ancient
General Councils, and from this we see that the Trullan Synod did not
reckon the Sardican among those councils, but after them. To this
it must be added that the highest Church authorities speak most
decidedly against the synod being ecumenical. We may appeal first
to Augustine, who only knew of the Eusebian assembly at Sardica, and
nothing at all of an orthodox synod in that place; which would have
been clearly impossible, if it had at that time been counted among the
ecumenical synods. Pope Gregory the Great Greg. M. Lib.
ii., Epist. 10.
and St. Isidore of Seville Isidor.
Hispal. Etymolog., Lib. vi., cap. 16. speak still more
plainly. They only know of four ancient General
Councils—those of Nice, Constantinople, Ephesus, and
Chalcedon. The objection of the Ballerini that Gregory and
Isidore did not intend to enumerate the most ancient general synods as
such, but only those which issued important dogmatic decrees, is
plainly quite arbitrary, and therefore without force. Under such
circumstances it is natural that among the later scholars by far the
great majority should have answered the question, whether the Synod of
Sardica is ecumenical, in the negative, as have Cardinal Bellarmin,
Peter de Marca, Edmund Richer, Fleury, Orsi, Sacharelli, Tillemont, Du
Pin, Berti, Ruttenstock, Rohrbacher, Remi Ceillier, Stolberg, Neander,
and others. On the other hand, Baronius, Natalis Alexander, the
brothers Ballerini, Mansi, and Palma Jno. Bapt. Palma.
Prælectiones Hist. Eccl. quas in Collegio Urbano habuit.
Rome, l838. Tom. i., P. ii., p. 85. have sought to
maintain the ecumenical character of the synod, but as early as the
seventeenth century the Roman censors condemned the direct assertions
of Natalis Alexander on the subject.