the anathematisms of Cyril were expressly confirmed at Chalcedon, there was even more
reason for doing so at Ephesus. And Ibas, in his well-known letter to Maris, says expressly
that the Synod of Ephesus confirmed the anathematisms of Cyril, and the same was asserted
even by the bishops of Antioch at Ephesus in a letter to the Emperor.
From all these considerations it would seem that Tillemont’s240 conclusion is well
founded that the Synod certainly discussed the anathemas of Cyril in detail, but that here,
as in many other places, there are parts of the Acts lacking. I shall add the opinion of
Petavius.
(Petavius, De Incarnatione, Lib. VI., cap. xvij.)
The Acts do not tell us what judgment the Synod of Ephesus gave with respect to the
third letter of Cyril, and with regard to the anathemas attached to it. But the Acts in other
respects also have not come down to us in their integrity. That that third letter was received
and approved by the Ephesine Council there can be no doubt, and this the Catholics shewed
in their dispute with the Acephali in the Collation held at Constantinople under the Emperor
Justinian in the year of Christ 811. For at that memorable meeting something was shewn
forth concerning this letter and its anathemas, which has a connexion with the matter in
hand, and therefore must not be omitted. At that meeting the Opposers, that is the
201
Acephali, the enemies of the Council of Chalcedon, made this objection against that
Council: “The [letter] of the Twelve Anathemas which is inserted in the holy Council of
Ephesus, and which you cannot deny to be synodical, why did not Chalcedon receive it?”
etc., etc.
From this it is evident that the prevailing opinion, then as now, was that the Twelve
Anathemas were defined as part of the faith by the Council of Ephesus. Perhaps I may close
this treatment of the subject in the words of Denziger, being the caption he gives the xij.
Anathematisms in his Enchiridion, under “Decrees of the Third Ecumenical Council, that
of Ephesus.” “The Third Synod received these anathematisms; the Fourth Synod placed
them in its Acts and styled the Epistles of Cyril ‘Canonical’; the Fifth Synod defended them.”
240 Tillemont, Mémoires. Tom. XIV., p. 405.
384
Historical Introduction to St. Cyril's Anathematisms.