to come in.”2148 You also read how he who was at first Saul, and afterwards Paul, was
compelled, by the great violence with which Christ coerced him, to know and to embrace
the truth; for you cannot but think that the light which your eyes enjoy is more precious to
men than money or any other possession. This light, lost suddenly by him when he was cast
to the ground by the heavenly voice, he did not recover until he became a member of the
Holy Church. You are also of opinion that no coercion is to be used with any man in order
to his deliverance from the fatal consequences of error; and yet you see that, in examples
which cannot be disputed, this is done by God, who loves us with more real regard for our
profit than any other can; and you hear Christ saying, “No man can come to me except the
Father draw him,”2149 which is done in the hearts of all those who, through fear of the wrath
of God, betake themselves to Him. You know also that sometimes the thief scatters food
384
before the flock that he may lead them astray, and sometimes the shepherd brings wandering
sheep back to the flock with his rod.
6. Did not Sarah, when she had the power, choose rather to afflict the insolent bondwo-
man? And truly she did not cruelly hate her whom she had formerly by an act of her own
kindness made a mother; but she put a wholesome restraint upon her pride.2150 Moreover,
as you well know, these two women, Sarah and Hagar, and their two sons Isaac and Ishmael,
are figures representing spiritual and carnal persons. And although we read that the bond-
woman and her son suffered great hardships from Sarah, nevertheless the Apostle Paul says
that Isaac suffered persecution from Ishmael: “But as then he that was born after the flesh
persecuted him that was born after the Spirit, even so it is now;”2151 whence those who have
understanding may perceive that it is rather the Catholic Church which suffers persecution
through the pride and impiety of those carnal men whom it endeavours to correct by afflic-
tions and terrors of a temporal kind. Whatever therefore the true and rightful Mother does,
even when something severe and bitter is felt by her children at her hands, she is not render-
ing evil for evil, but is applying the benefit of discipline to counteract the evil of sin, not
with the hatred which seeks to harm, but with the love which seeks to heal. When good and
bad do the same actions and suffer the same afflictions, they are to be distinguished not by
what they do or suffer, but by the causes of each: e.g. Pharaoh oppressed the people of God
by hard bondage; Moses afflicted the same people by severe correction when they were guilty
of impiety:2152 their actions were alike; but they were not alike in the motive of regard to
the people’s welfare,—the one being inflated by the lust of power, the other inflamed by
2148 Luke xiv. 23.
2149 John vi. 44.
2150 Gen. xvi. 5.
2151 Gal. iv. 29.
2152 Ex. v. 9 and xxxii. 27.
849
To Vincentius