It
was a point in controversy with the extreme Monophysites, that is, the
Eutychians, whether our Lord’s body was naturally subject to
death, the Catholics maintaining the affirmative, as Athanasius here.
Eutyches asserted that our Lord had not a human nature, by which he
meant among other things that His manhood was not subject to the
laws of a body, but so far as He submitted to them, He did so by
an act of will in each particular case; and this, lest it should seem
that He was moved by the πάθη against His
will ἀκουσίως; and consequently that His manhood was not subject to
death. But the Catholics maintained that He had voluntarily placed
Himself under those laws, and died naturally, vid. Athan.
contr. Apol. i. 17, and that after the resurrection His body
became incorruptible, not according to nature, but by grace. vid.
Leont. de Sect. x. p. 530. Anast. Hodeg. c. 23. To
express their doctrine of the ὑπερφυές of our Lord’s manhood the Eutychians made use of the
Catholic expression ‘ut voluit.’ vid. Athan. l.c. Eutyches
ap. Leon. Ep. 21. ‘quomodo voluit et scit,’ twice.
vid. also Eranist. i. p. 11. ii. p. 105. Leont. contr.
Nest. i. p. 967. Pseudo-Athan. Serm. adv. Div. Hær.
§8. (t. 2. p. 570.)